Is High-Intensity Exercise More of a Mood Booster Than Steady-State Cardio?

Is High-Intensity Exercise More of a Mood Booster Than Steady-State Cardio?

(Last Updated On: June 19, 2019)

high-intensity exercise

Have you ever launched into a workout feeling slightly down or maybe a little “stressed out?” But by the end of the workout, your mind had cleared and your mood has lifted. That’s the magic of exercise! Research shows regular physical activity benefits brain function in more than one way. Not only can it spur the growth of new nerve cells in part of the brain involved in memory, a process called neurogenesis, it also boosts mood. Yes, the “feel good” effect of exercise is real, and it’s one reason people keep doing it. Beyond the known health benefits, exercising regularly helps you maintain a healthy state of mind and better deal with stress.

We know that longer-term exercise has physical and mental health benefits. But what about a single, vigorous bout of exercise, a high-intensity interval training session? What impact does it have on mood? According to some research, 30 minutes of high-intensity exercise rivals anti-depressant medications for lifting the mood of people suffering from depression. It’s not clear why intense exercise boosts mood, but a theory is that the endorphin release you get from a kick-butt workout has beneficial effects on the brain and on mood.

What’s so special about endorphins? They’re natural chemicals your brain produces that have a pain-relieving, calming effect. Your brain makes more endorphins when you’re in pain or are under stress, as during challenging exercise. Fortunately, it’s a good kind of stress! The purpose of endorphin release is to mask the discomfort and ease the pain of working your body to the max. In fact, these chemicals are similar to opioid medications people take for severe pain. They also bring about feelings of calm, peace, and pleasure. So, it’s not hard to see why exercise is a mood booster. It’s also not difficult to see why more health care professionals are prescribing exercise for stress management and for dealing with anxiety and depression.

With regard to interval training and depression, an article in American Family Physician:

“Adequate trials on the role interval training plays in depression are lacking, but there are indications that the physiological changes brought about by high-intensity interval exercise are greater and longer lasting compared with changes from aerobic or resistance training.” So, high-intensity interval training may be the ticket to a better mood.

The Impact of High-Intensity Exercise on Anxiety

The endorphin release and mood boost that comes with vigorous exercise seems to lift the spirits of people who are down and those who are clinically depressed, based on preliminary studies. But the impact on anxiety is less clear. In one study, 20 male soccer players took part in a high-intensity interval training workout. The session lasted a total of 28 minutes and consisted of 4 minutes of active work followed by 3 minutes of recovery for a total of 28 minutes. Beforehand, the subjects responded to a questionnaire called the Profile of Mood State or POMS. This questionnaire is designed to measure mood state, how angry, tense, down, or tired you feel. The test was repeated afterward.

Surprisingly, the players scored higher for anxiety and fatigue after the high-intensity interval session. They also reported a reduction in “vigor,” or energy. The fatigue and a decrease in vigor was probably due to fatigue, but the increased anxiety score is more interesting. Can high-intensity interval training increase anxiety in some people?

Why might high-intensity exercise increase anxiety rather than reduce it? Intense workouts activate the sympathetic or fight-or-flight nervous system. In response, your body pumps out more hormone-like chemicals like adrenalin that prepare your body to fight or run by raising blood pressure and heart rate and by increasing alertness. Even after an intense workout is over, these chemicals remain in the bloodstream for a while. Since they’re activating, an intense workout session might temporarily make a person feel anxious if that person is prone toward anxiety. How an exercise session affects anxiety levels may depend on the balance between endorphins and fight-or-flight hormones. In some people, the endorphin effect may be stronger and intense exercise calms them. In others, the adrenalin effect may win out and they feel more hyped up and anxious. We’re all a little different, even in how we respond to exercise.

Another way exercise may quell anxious thoughts, independent of the brain chemical effects, is by distracting the mind from worries and obsessive thoughts. A vigorous workout can help break a cycle of negative thoughts and restore tranquility. Plus, regular physical activity of any type builds confidence because you’re mastering new skills and moving your body in new ways. Introducing variety into a workout also keeps motivation high and the challenge alive.

All in all, it’s less clear whether longer term, high-intensity interval training reduces anxiety. All in all, the evidence that high-intense interval training alleviates depressive symptoms is stronger than the evidence that it reduces anxiety.

Keep It Balanced

If high-intensity workout can potentially boost anxiety in some people, it’s important to moderate it. Stick to a few 2 or 3 sessions per week. Pushing the body too hard can increase the release of stress hormones that fuel anxiety. Balance high-intensity workouts with ones that help your body recover, like yoga. Sometimes it’s tempting to push too hard, but, ultimately, it’s about balance.

The Bottom Line

High-intensity exercise is good for your waistline but it’s also good for your brain. If you’re feeling down or have had bouts of depression, there’s growing evidence that high-intensity interval training may help. The evidence is less clear for anxiety. But at the very least, it’s a good way to distract yourself from worries and do something good for your body at the same time.

 

References:

·        Science & Sports. Volume 33, Issue 4, September 2018, Pages e151-e157.

·        VeryWellMind.com. “Exercise and Improving Your Mood”

·        J Exp Psychol Learn Mem Cogn. 2014 Jul;40(4):1142-52. doi: 10.1037/a0036577. Epub 2014 Apr 21.

 

Related Articles By Cathe:

How Long Does It Take for Exercise to Boost Your Mood? Would You Believe Only 10 Minutes?

How High-Intensity Exercise Makes Your Brain More Efficient

Memory Jolt: Can a Workout Instantly Improve Your Memory?

Exercise is Good for Your Brain as Long as You Make It a Habit

The Mood-Enhancing Benefits of Exercise: Why You Feel So Good After a Workout

What’s the Best Exercise for Anxiety?

5 Reasons Exercise is the Closest Thing to a Happy Pill

The Negative Effects Stopping Exercise Has on Your Mood

 

Related Cathe Friedrich Workout DVDs:

HiiT, Metabolic, and Interval Workout DVDs

2 thoughts on “Is High-Intensity Exercise More of a Mood Booster Than Steady-State Cardio?

  1. Since, I have been doing Cathe workouts, I have found that doing anything helps my mood! Doing the Cathe Strength Workouts actually helps my flexibility more then cardio ever did! What I find with anything Cathe (not stretching) she gets your pulse up! I thought doing strength workouts that wouldn’t happen, but it does! I like doing Cathe workouts instead of jogging! I noticed I haven’t been depressed since doing Cathe workouts. I am like this if you can get your heart pumping it doesn’t matter if it is a HIIT workout or a steady Step Workout. As long as it is pumping faster. That is what I find. I have done group workouts, but I find Cathe workouts get my heart pumping more then those other instructors!

  2. For a mood booster, as for HIIT, I am like this, doing anything I find helps your mood! And I love that Cathe is really positive and her voice is perfect. Her voice isn’t to high or to low! It is right where it should be!!! Just do any Cathe workout, even her stretching workout and I bet you will feel better for at least an hour or two!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.