I think Morningstar's point is, if you need or want a modifier, why be relegated to watching a little picture in the corner of the screen?
Sorry I misunderstood!
I was just thinking that it would be better than nothing. Especially since some people seemed bothered by the idea of a modifier in with the group.
I'm in general agreement with most here. I don't think modifiers detract from a strong production. Michelle Dozois, Kathy Smith and others do it just fine without wreaking havoc with intensity or aesthetics.
What strikes me about the poll is that a good number of us have been exercising with Cathe for years (or are looking forward to being with her for years.)
It would behoove SNM to understand that even as they widen their market base, a notable segment is getting older and have changing needs.
We still like and need intensity and the professionalism that Cathe provides in quality workouts. But we need consideration for bodies that can't take impact anymore.
We want the option of going with or without impact and getting the intensity, safety and results Cathe has always delivered.