American Idol

Okay
My top 3 are...
Melinda
Lakeesha
Jordin
Please get rid of Antonella! Yes she is pretty but come on....
Ok can y'all tell I am addicted?
I've never really watched this show until this season.
Ok I am going to go to bed now! LOL
I lead such a wild life !!:D
LD
 
Okay, Melinda owned it last night. She is consistently awesome. I also enjoyed rocking out to Evanescence....way cool. Gina was in her element & stood out. Please someone put Antonella & Haley out of their misery.


Debbie


Adults are always asking kids what they want to be when they grow up because they are looking for ideas.
--Paula Poundstone
 
Yeah, Melinda was very good last night! I hope Antonella doesn't make it through another week. I only like one of the guys, but I forget his name...:)
 
My top 3 are also Melinda, Lakisha and Jordan. The guys are going to have a tough fight ahead of them. I hope Antonella and Sanjay leave so they can put us out of our misery.
 
I think the guys should pack it in, personally. It is a shame that a decent girl singer ( and I don't mean Antoinella!) is losing her spot tonight to make room for a totally nondescript male singer. I don't even remember them from week to week!

Melinda is the bomb, and definitely has the "yo" factor!!!:7
 
>Okay, Melinda owned it last night. She is consistently
>awesome. I also enjoyed rocking out to Evanescence....way
>cool. Gina was in her element & stood out. Please someone put
>Antonella & Haley out of their misery.
>
>
>Debbie
>

In total agreement!:)
 
Luckily, there are two female contestants that are expendible (Antoinella and Haley) and if they go tonight, everything will be okay. But I wonder if the "vote for the worst" crew will keep one of them around, and knock one of the other women off. That would be a shame.

I had to laugh after Haley (whose name I counldn't remember either) sang and Simon said it sounded like a bad High School musical performance. I was thinking the exact same thing (it sounded like a high school performance) while she was singing.

And Antoinella actually did better last night, I thought, than she had previously...at least for 3/4 of her song. But she doesn't seem able to keep on key for an entire song.

At least once the top 12 are chosen, there won't be some lame "X-many 'girls' and X-many 'boys'" rule, and most of the guys can hit the road (that is, if people vote fairly, and not just to screw up the contest. Though if it's like previous years, several not-so-good singers will outlast some better ones).

Lakisha is back! I thought her performance last week wasn't as good as the first week, but last night she was back! I thought the judges---who usually caution contestants about singing songs by Mariah, or Whitney or Christina or Celine: all the singers will 'pipes'--would say something about how they usually worry about it, but Lakisha did a great job on a Whitney tune.

My favorites so far are Lakisha, Melinda and the woman with the long tight curls (I'm aweful with names).

This could be a really interesting season if those three get into the top 4.
 
I totally am a Melinda Doolittle fan. I can not for the life of me stand Antonella. She is in major denial about where she stands in this contest. I hate the fact that she even made it this far, and this girl cannot hold a tune throughout an entire song. She is an average singer that probably took the two songs she mastered and did that at auditions. I can't believe she tried singing Celine last week. I hate to be so critical, but everytime she sings, eugh. And I also feel like Haley needs to go. Didn't like her performance last week and what song was she singing last night? She should go back home and be with her fiance. But let's go Melinda!

Lisa
 
OK I just have to say HUH???? Ok good to get rid of Antonella but what is up with Sanja? And that girl! Oh my. I just don't get it.
Well at least that worst website lost both of their front runners.
LD
 
I can't believe Sanjaya is still in the running. Who is voting for him? What's with Haley still there too. That's to bad Sundance had to go and the girl with the curly hair. I am not good with names either. I really like Gina though. She has a strong voice and I like her song choices.
 
What in the bleepity bleep happened tonight? I agree with Simon. I think people accidentally turned down the volume on their TVs. AIYEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE! Hopefully those gems will get weeded out very soon.

Oh yeah, ETA Carrie Underwood is awesome, and I'm not a huge country fan. Whoot.


Debbie


Adults are always asking kids what they want to be when they grow up because they are looking for ideas.
--Paula Poundstone
 
Finally America got it right with kicking off Antonella, but I am very sad to see Sabrina go--she was one of my favorites. Sanjaya really needs to go! Did you see the looks on the judges faces when they he said Sanjaya was staying? Wow!
 
Yo dawgs. Here's a great quote from EW's site that is awesome. LOLtastic even. A fan wrote in:


Tom Fri, Mar 9, 2007 at 6:19 AM EST
It would be great if Sanjaya won the whole thing. I think that would force the producers to change the voting process. Others in the past have suggested letting us vote to eliminate the worst, rather than voting for our favorites. I think that would reduce the amount of "Chicken Littles" we would have to endure every season.



Debbie


Adults are always asking kids what they want to be when they grow up because they are looking for ideas.
--Paula Poundstone
 
You know I'm almost a little embarassed for Sanjaya. He's just not very good. IMO Melinda and Lakisha should just go off and record their albums right now. I'm not very happy about the results last night. At least Antonella was sent home. I'm sure she'll find success with "Girls Gone Wild". It's such a shame that beautiful young girls think that they have to resort to undressing themselves to get attention and fame.

Chastity

http://www.picturetrail.com:80/chastgirl0205
 
Crap!
Well, two 'clunkers' got into the top 12, leaving 2 more deserving candidates out the door.

Is this the doing of "vote for the worst"?

I think it's horribly unfair.

I wasn't really hooked on Sundance, but he was much better than Sanjaya (who seems like a nice kid, but really...). The woman with long curly hair who got booted while Haley stayed (!) WAS one of my favorites. Hope she gets a career boost from being in the top 20.

Maybe there should be some voting reform, like each phone number can only vote once?
 
I actually felt sorry for Sanjaya last night. Did you see the judges reactions? Poor guy.
Vote for the worst lost both of their picks so I don't know if that has much to do with it.
I agree that they need to limit the number of times you can vote.
JMO
LD
 
I felt sorry for Sanjaya too, but he really has to go. I can't believe he beat out Sundance. I think Sabrina should have stayed too. Hopefully, good things will happen for her. I really like Lakisha, Gina and Melinda for the girls. For the guys, I like Blake and Chris R. Chris S. is pretty funny though and not a "bad" singer.

I agree, I think they need a new voting system, but I do think the ones with real talent end up making it. Look at Jennifer Hudson and Chris Daughtry. Love that guy!! Hope this season gets some spunk like last season. Bring back Chris!!! LOL!:7

Dallas
 
I know why Sanjaya is still there...because 11 year old girls have cell phones!!!

One of my co-workers has a pre-teen daughter and apparently Sanjaya is the favorite of her and most of her friends. Oye!
 
I was shocked to see Sabrina and Sundance go! I just knew that little Hula boy would make it! You are right that the young girls love Sanjaya. I bet he makes the next round too! Hey, at least Anotella is gone.

ETA: I have to admit. I have not voted yet. I'm going to start voting next week.
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top