I don't get it. What is it about Supercuts and Afterburn that you think disqualifies them from being true metabolic training and relegates them o the level of "just circuits"?
Dirtdiva: I'm with you on the longer, full body workouts and I'm not convinced about the "don't work for longer than an hour dreaded cortisol effect" either. Longer workouts work for me too. We all need to know what works for us.
Clare
Without turning the discussion into a personal attack, I will reply to your post.
First of all I will list 4 fitness components:
speed, stamina, strength and flexibility. Plus Balance.
Endurance==Circuits with high reps Examples: Supercuts, afterburn and Body max (Any of them)
The individual meet the purpose of acquiring or maintaining stamina. Slow twitch come into play.
This meet the
"cut" purpose, should there be any muscles.
Cut===CATABOLISM
Hypertrophy==Less reps/Heavy lifting 80% Rep max Example ( Muscle Max, STS total there is not that many plus Upcoming RWH), the individual meet speed, strength and flexibility
Yes heavy lifting help in gaining some flexibility. Do not get me wrong...yoga is great though
Fast twitch come into play.
This does trigger production of friendly hormone meeting the
building purpose. Endurance does not much.
Building===ANABOLISM
I am not going to add any article. There are tons on advantage of Hiit and lifting heavy versus circuit/metabolic.
Should anyone against evidence about cortisol production, please report any dis-impression to sport research regulatory obodies
From my experience long steady stuff bring boredom. Do not get me wrong I am not implying LONG steady should not be
done. It is all about training on a balanced rotation basis.
Now Excessive high circuits compared to a reasonable ratio of a rotation covering Endurance, hyperthrophy and strength
is
NOT what is suitable to anyone regardless of the body type. High circuit claiming to work for someone from the "claiming aesthetic"
point of view, it is not what I would recommend. I personally would run miles away from a trainer who solely recommend circuit.
I would also run far away from any trainer operating based on what works "best" for her/him
.
To finish my post...
Athletes work extremely hard covering each components regardless of what they love the most.
That is the attitude i would advise anyone, striving for an athletic body, to have.
Just saying!
My post may sound too technical but I could not explain any other way.
Peace everyone