Ha! Roz, we must have been typing at the same time.....
I know what you mean about everything else seeming like 'metabolic weight training'. It's only listening to you two (Karen, you're implicated here) that I realised what I've been doing for years is almost exclusively metabolic or hypertrophy work. As you say, even STS meso #3 has more reps than Nia. What hooked me and drew me in to Nia's programme was that she's tiny and doesn't look like she could pick up a chopstick, let alone 300+lbs. (Until you see her muscles ripple if she's wearing a vest and shorts.) I'm the other way round - I look muscular, but I'm relatively weak. Yes, too many hypertrophy programmes for me.
I came across Nia a couple of years ago, subscribed, and got a free w/o plan - but it looked too simple, and I didn't have the nerve to try it. Thought it couldn't possibly work. It was listening to Karen and Roz which made me finally take the plunge. I've seen the light! (well, the heavy, actually.)
Thanks girls.
All right, you got me without even trying, Justine. LOL.
I always return to metabolic workouts, even though I know I probably ought to branch out more often into different territory. I admit it, I have been über-skeptical of the short-workout movement taking off as of late. Well, it's been taking off for a couple of years minimum, but I'm probably way late to the game, so it's new to me! I must have some sort of 1980's aerobics class mental block (along with a lifetime of obesity behind me) pushing my brain to fight against accepting short workouts as equal or superior, no matter how intense they are. And I know they
are intense, at least in Nia Shanks' case. It is so ingrained in my brain, "Work out for an hour (or close to it), sweat your tail off, or don't even bother." The thought of doing 1-5 reps or 6 exercises or so for a few sets only? What?! I just do not feel like I'll ever keep my weight down if I did that. I'll think, "Yeah, I'm sure that it works for the already trim who just want to stay nice and firm and fit plus gain some muscle, but for a big chick like me? Yeah, right!" I know pretty much anyone would gain muscle on it, but the fat-burning part...can anyone address that for me?
I've seen examples of Nia's program (or the workouts Marianne Kane does, another example of a kickbutt lady- you ought to see her Bulgarian split squats!!!) and it looks so nice and simple and enticing. But wow...I don't know. Is the calorie burn
really the same? Can a Nia Shanks program work for those who tend towards obesity, or is it really only best for those who are generally of normal (or near it) weight, and just want more muscle? Don't get me wrong, I absolutely believe that Nia's program would build muscle like it's nobody's business. But is it/would it be enough for people who have a lot of weight to lose (20+ pounds) and/or have a far higher genetic tendency to get obese? I am not judging one way or the other, I truly don't know the answer. I am also aware that there probably
is no one-size-fits-all answer. I am curious if anyone who started out with significant weight to lose followed Nia Shanks program succeeded in reaching their goal weight and keeping weight off for a year or more. I've hit about nine months of maintaining my weight loss, and I can tell you it takes a ton of work! I almost feel like the rule book is not written the same for someone like me, that I don't have the luxury of choosing shorter workouts, although I freely admit I could be wrong.
Another thing that's entirely mental yet again...Although I might be nuts, I really
like working out for 45-70 minutes a day. It's
my time, strictly set aside just for myself and the whole household knows it!
I adore the variety of cross-training with tons of different exercises. I also actually enjoy finishing a workout knowing that I completely gave all of myself to it, and am utterly spent. Not
every workout can or should be that way, but many of them have to be for me or I'm not all that pleased with my efforts. Maybe that's out-of-balance? I don't know. Does Nia's program leave you feeling like, "Wow, that's the utter limit of my ability today!"? Again, I could be completely wacky, but I so love reaching the point of being drenched in sweat after a workout and having put in significant time to the challenge. Sorry if this is going way beyond the scope of questions I ought to ask here, but I am truly interested in any answers.