For those who don't count calories...

jennifermaria

Cathlete
Hi everyone,

For those of you who don't count calories, how do you generally get a sense that you're eating enough/not too much? I know Tosca Reno talks about listening to the body's hunger cues, but sometimes those cues can be a bit misleading, particularly for people who are really, really active, which can create some unpredictability in how hunger manifests itself.

As I train for a marathon, for example, I can either be REALLY famished after a long run--so raging with hunger that I could eat a ginormous meal and STILL want to eat another one right after--I could easily (and, I'm ashamed to say, have sometimes) exceed my calorie requirement for the day if I just went off my hunger cues.

On the other hand, there are days when I'm not feeling too much hunger, and yet according to my calorie requirement, I need to be eating a certain amount and I haven't met that calorie count yet.

I want to be as consistent as possible in getting what I'm supposed to be getting--no more, no less--because it impacts my performance, not to mention, I could end up losing muscle if it's too little (not usually the problem--99% of the time it's the other way around LOL). I do count calories for that reason, but I do find that I get a little too anal about it, and I would love the freedom of just being able to be intuitive about how much I'm eating.

I should mention that I eat fairly cleanly. I'd say I'm 90% clean--I allow myself indulgences here and there, but for the most part, I try and stick to minimally processed foods, try to get at least (if not more than) the minimum daily requirement for fruits and vegetables, calcium/dairy products, whole grain, healthy fats, etc. But there are days when I eat the calories I'm supposed to and am still famished, and still others (albeit not so frequently) when I haven't even met the requirement yet, and I'm full/content.

How can I eat according to my hunger cues if my hunger cues aren't quite reliable yet? Are there other methods to try while those get in synch? Should I stick to calorie counting so I'm a little more accurate (realizing that nothing is 100% accurate, as they're all estimates)?

Thanks in advance!

Jennifer
 
Hi Jennifer,

I used to run marathons and on the days when I did my long runs, I would eat oatmeal and a banana before my run. During the run I would use gels or dates and after my run I would eat protein which is what my body was craving. This should help with not eating too much the rest of the day.

Josie
 
I run marathons, too! I always eat (no matter what) about 20-30 minutes after a long run or any tough workout. Other than that, I always eat when I am hungry. I am a vegetarian, so the vast majority of foods I choose to eat are healthy anyway.

There are days when I eat a ton and days when I eat very little. It has worked for me my whole life...always have been about 110-114 pounds and work out like crazy - I just always listen to my hunger. If I am starving in the morning, I eat a TON, then I end up not being hungry at night (and v/v)...always worked for me. If I am hungry at 4 am, I eat. You will get used to listening to your hunger cues! Good luck with your training.
 
I have been an avid calorie counter for 2 yrs now. I cannot imagine how many calories I was eating before !! :eek: Maybe writing it all down has made me more aware & I would be better at gaging now. Hats off to thos eof you who have it all figured out w/o counting!! :D
 
I have never really been a calorie counter. That's too much organization for me. I just eat when I'm hungry and stop before I'm full. I know what food is bad food and only eat it once in awhile and never have snacks worse than Orville Reddenbacher's Smart Pop in the house. If my pants are getting too tight, I know I've been eating too much.
 
I have never really been a calorie counter. That's too much organization for me. I just eat when I'm hungry and stop before I'm full. I know what food is bad food and only eat it once in awhile and never have snacks worse than Orville Reddenbacher's Smart Pop in the house. If my pants are getting too tight, I know I've been eating too much.


Pretty much the same for me.
 
i've just started calorie counting and food journaling. It's a horrible sight at the end of the day! I think it is starting to make me think twice before popping food in my mouth...knowing I have to record it. I don't find my hunger cues at all reliable, probably because of years of cycling between binging and starving? Maybe it comes back when you get more in tune with your body?
 
I eat 4 or 5 times a day and generally eat pretty clean. I eat to satisfy and never to be full. (I can't remember the last time I said I ate too much.) With this kind of plan, I'm never overly hungry and apparently I eat enough! On days where I have intense cardio, I may throw in more grains as I do feel hungrier, or intense weight training, I up my protein intake. It's all about balance. I couldn't begin to tell you how many calories I eat. But I do listen to my body and I can tell if I need more carbs or protein or whatever and I eat accordingly.

Jo
 
I have run a few marathons too and I am always hungrier those days. But think about it, if you run for 3 hours you are burning tons of calories and need to replenish them. Ironically I always gain a few pounds when I train for a marathon because my thigh muscles always get bigger. I do lots of hill work in prep for a marathon.
 
I have run a few marathons too and I am always hungrier those days. But think about it, if you run for 3 hours you are burning tons of calories and need to replenish them. Ironically I always gain a few pounds when I train for a marathon because my thigh muscles always get bigger. I do lots of hill work in prep for a marathon.
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top