acupuncture or chiropractor

janie1234

Cathlete
Has anyone tried either of these for lower back pain? I've been back to training harder for a triathlon next year and I've noticed some ache in my lower back that I have not been able to shake off. The whole back cracking thing freaks me out but I guess being poked by a bunch of needles doesn't sound like a walk in the park either.
 
I've not had acupuncture myself, but have several friends who utilize an acupuncturist on a regular basis. They love it! They all started going when everything else they tried failed to help them and every one of them wished they had started there.

I've always wanted to go to one, but have just never gotten around to it. Do your research on them to find a good one!

Good luck!
 
Just a thought, how about massage? My Massage therapist is also a licensed accupuncturist, but I stick with the massage. She has managed to right all sorts of wrongs, and can tell me the cause of most of my pains by identifying where the pain stems from.

Good luck with your triathlon :D
 
Just a thought, how about massage? My Massage therapist is also a licensed accupuncturist, but I stick with the massage. She has managed to right all sorts of wrongs, and can tell me the cause of most of my pains by identifying where the pain stems from.

Good luck with your triathlon :D

Hi Melissa thanks, . . .I actually get a deep tissue every month to two months. It does wonders for my shoulders, legs and upper back but not my lower back. :(
 
I'd like to know if many have had positive responses with lower back issues and acupuncture as well. This disc and sciatica is driving me bonkers. We have ONE acupuncturist in town and I'm tempted to give it a try.

Good luck with your training - hope the lower back issues don't slow down your training process:( Go easy with that back. Trust me, it's not worth it to overdo it!

Heidi
 
Pain, and specifically back pain, is one of the very few things that Acupuncture has been proven to be effective for. I don't like chiropractors and have actually been injured by one, so I will never recommend going to them. I love Acupuncture for pain and stress; it just makes you feel so relaxed and after a few sessions, the pain is gone.
 
I would try the chiropractor for the back but thats just me, I had a good one and he made a great deal of difference for my neck post car accident. But, that said, yoga made an even bigger effect on my whole skeleton than any cardio, dieting or chiropractic care ever did. You might look into a physical therapist. Sometimes they know great exercises that fix the body without needing hands on care from a doctor.
 
I personally LOVE my chiropractor. My sciatica was a disaster at the beginning of this pregnancy and my chiropractor and massage therapist together pretty much eliminated it. I haven't had any back pain at all since starting up with them both. I've been alternating between the two of them throughout the entire pregnancy. I wish I could take them both to the hospital with me. Like Morningstar though, I have had a bad experience with a chiropractor too. You really have to research them. Some are great, some are quacks.
 
I've never had acupuncture but would love to try it. I have however been to several chiros and (insert singing voice) looooove them! Just this morning I had this weird knotty feeling in my hip...went to my lovely chiro and the knot is GONE! :D
 
Janie1234: I've heard great things about accupuncture for low back pain. A good accupuncturist will tell you, up front, that if the treatment doesn't help significantly by the 3rd session, it probably will not work. As far as the chiropractor, depending on your specific back issues, you may only get a "manipulation" and probably not the "back cracking" you are thinking. I had one chiropractor that would just gently massage my low back area. That same chiropractor also did accupunture. You definitely want to research & interview for a chiro. Like people have said, there are good ones and bad ones.

I have tried both chiropractic care and accupunture in the past year. Neither of them helped me(or hurt me) with my lower back issues. It didn't make my symptoms better or worse, just didn't do anything. I will mention that even though I have low back problems (spinal stenosis & spondylolisthesis), I do not have any pain in my back; it's all in my right hip, leg, and calf. Anyway, what has helped are 3 cortisone epidural injections for my back(to get the inflammation down), 2 bursitis shots for my hip, physical therapy with exercises specifically to strengthen my core, and tons of lower body stretching. Recently, I added pilates to the mix, and wow, has that helped!

Whatever treatment route you seek remember to listen to your body, voice your concerns, ask questions, bring a note pad to take notes, bring a list of all the symptoms you have, and trust your instincts. Gee, can you tell I've been to a doctor, chiro, and PT or 2 or 3??:D
 
My chiropractor has worked MIRACLES for my sacral area!!! So let me vote a big yes for the chiro for low back pain. He's the only person that's been able to adjust the area correctly and keep me pain free. I'm 31 weeks pregnant with my second right now, and the differences between this and my last pregnancy are remarkable becuase of him.
He's actually improved the curvature of my spine, which given how distorted it is right now really says something.

Massage is nice, but I needed someone to actually release the area. It takes some contortion, but I've been largely pain free in that area as a result. No more sciatica!!!
 
I have had acupunture for my low back it it worked amazingly well. My needle doctor was also a licensed chiropractor so he 'cracked' my back as well.

I was in chronic back pain for a year before I went to him and was 80% better after one visit. My problem was I have a slight curve and compressed disc which my muscles were trying to compensate for and became chronically tight/sore/knotted and regularly spasmed.

The needle doctor was a chinese man - trained in china. He put the needles in my low back and then attached electrodes to them to send pulses to the muscles through the needles. It sounds odd but it really worked! I felt the pulses but it wasn't pain - felt like tiny contractions around the needles.

Then he did cupping on my back which increased the circulation in that area - but I almost passed out for some reason. The next time, I didn't have a reaction.

Then he cracked my back and I was on my way. I went back about 6 more times and while I sometimes feel stiffness there, I haven't had the same level of pain since - that was about 5 years ago.

About 5 years prior to that, I had chronic neck/shoulder pain - due to 2 pregnancies in 2 years (one was a twin pregnancy) and then carrying the babies around/stress, etc. I went to a chiropractor who did deep massage work on my knots along with adjustments and that worked too.

Between the two - the acupuncture worked faster for me, but both did work and they were different problems so I can't say one is better than the other. I think the added things the accupunturist did for me helped me recover faster (the electrical stimulation and chiro adjustments specifically)
 
Last edited:
From the experiences of DH and I, chiropractic in conjunction with various massage techniques (deep tissue, myofascial, etc) can work wonders. Our chiro will sometimes have us see one of the massage therapists on staff to get the muscles relaxed before an adjustment...that stuff is all connected.

I also LOVE my chiro and his staff.

I don't have first-hand experience with acupuncture, but a colleague of mine did. She said it helped a lot with her sciatica. FWIW, I think she was referred to it by her chiropractor.

Janie - Do you foam roll? Just because of all of the stuff I do, I tend to beat the sh!t out of my lower back area. Faithful foam rolling in my back, hips, ITB, leg areas helps tremendously.

HTH
 
Janie - Do you foam roll? Just because of all of the stuff I do, I tend to beat the sh!t out of my lower back area. Faithful foam rolling in my back, hips, ITB, leg areas helps tremendously.

HTH

Hiya Gayle! I just bought a grid foam roller and I've been using it everyday on my low back. It has been great!
I was curious if acupunture or a chiropractor would help even more. I feel like the older I get the worse my posture gets, . . which is funny because I used to dance ballet and posture was soooo important. It seems like everything just I also have a theory that it could be kidney related, . . which I hope not. As much as I love Dr.'s I hate going because most of the time they just want to medicate me and get me the hell outta there to see the next patient. It makes me feel like I'm just being a hypocondriac and that my symptoms don't really exist. I know that chiro's and acupuncturist are sometimes considered "fake" Dr.s but I wonder if somehow they would help more than a medical Dr.
What is the going rate for a chiro or acupuncturist visit?
 
The needle doctor was a chinese man - trained in china.

Then he did cupping on my back which increased the circulation in that area - but I almost passed out for some reason. The next time, I didn't have a reaction.

Actually that is what I was hoping to find. A Chinese acupunturist/chiro . . . . I hear that the cupping works too. I'd love to try that. Did it hurt? I wonder why you almost passed out?
 
It didn't hurt, I just started feeling light headed - I think it was from blood leaving my head and rushing to that area. It feels like suction and warm.

Good luck finding the right care provider.
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top