>>Ditto JTreddin!
>>
>>I guess music doesn't really make or break a workout for me.
>>As long as the workout is good and the music "fits" (i.e.
>>upbeat in a cardio segment and more mellow in a stretch) I'm
>a
>>happy camper. Yes there are some songs that I hear and make
>me
>>psyched like 'About a Girl' by Nirvana on SJP during the
>bicep
>>work...OMG I about fell out when I heard that, even DH
>walked
>>in and said Cathe is using Nirvana? Too cool! There are
>other
>>songs here and there that give an extra WOW factor but
>Cathe's
>>workouts are the BOMB and I'd love them regardless of the
>>style of music. Really think about it people...my taste are
>>Pink Floyd, Nirvana, Pearl Jam, The Doors...the next person
>>may like country or gospel. How in the world can one person
>>pick music that ALL of us love? It's not possible and I
>think
>>it puts an unfair burden on Cathe. Maybe a "music off"
>option
>>would solve this issue? Something for SNM to consider in the
>>future to avoid this discussion.
>>
>>Keep up the great work Cathe and thank you for ALL that you
>do
>>for us!!
>
>I don't want to turn the music off and just b/c we voice a
>dissenting opinion in hopes that something will change for
>future workouts doesn't mean we are less appreciative of the
>workouts Cathe produces. She has consistenly delivered on the
>"BOMB" workouts and has always been open to suggestions and
>constructive criticism. As you said, it is impossible to
>please everyone all the time, but it doesn't hurt to hear
>everyone's opinion to help with future choices. That being
>said, the music may be fabulous since we've only heard 6
>minutes of it. I'm not trying to sound harsh but I just think
>people ought to allow posters to give their opinion to Cathe
>on her forum without a come on people or a slap on the hand.
>Angela
>P.S. I just finished a late night workout...Muscle Max...I
>guess I'm feeling a little bit fisty!
Ooh, I totally didn't mean to come off as "don't give constructive criticism"; I'm sorry if my post read that way...it was not my intention. And I certainly didn't mean that people who are disappointed in the music choice were less appreciative of Cathe's workouts. So I'm sorry if anyone took my post as a "slap on the hand".
I guess the point I was trying to make is that music is so subjective that no matter what she chooses there will always be a group that is disappointed. There really isn't a win-win solution in my opinion other than offering a music off function in the future. That way people could play their own music should they find the music choice disappointing. That being said, your point about "the music may be fabulous since we've only heard 6 minutes of it" is very true. I supose we'll have to wait and see after everyone gets the workouts. I suspect, however, that the jury will still be split thus leaving the options of 1. keeping the next series' music similar or 2. going to more recognizable songs...either way one side is going to be disappointed.