I'm also an Aquaphor believer. But, I think it just takes trial and error to figure out what works for you. I have a tub of Aquaphor in my bathroom and a small tube I carry in my purse. Then I had Chapstick extra moisturizing (or some such) that I also carry around and have everywhere--kitchen, office, purse, car, overnight bag, gym bag, etc. I use them interchangeably.