The homeschool decision
I've been homeschooling since my oldest was in kindergarten. She's now in 7th grade, and I have 3 other children I'm teaching as well. In terms of instilling my morals and values, I agree with what others have said. This is my time to help prepare my children to face serious pressures, much heavier than anything we had to deal with as kids. If they have a strong foundation, they are more likely to be able to withstand those pressures. Plus if we have built a strong family relationship, they are more likely to know they can count on us if they DO get in over their heads. I'm not saying that you can't do that with your kids in a public school, but that it can be harder because so much of the time your kids aren't with you.
I also like the fact that I can tailor the program to the needs of each individual child. What worked well in history with my older daughter wasn't working at all last year for her sister. We started over trying different teaching techniques 3 times when it became clear that she wasn't "getting it," and eventually changed history programs altogether. On the other end, that same daughter was bored silly with the math we were doing because it was too easy. We began letting her "test out" of chapters by demonstrating at least 90% comprehension on the chapter tests. Then on chapters where she wasn't able to achieve 90%, she worked through the whole thing. So at the same time she was in a holding pattern with history while we tried to figure out what would work for her, she was charging ahead in math at mach speed. A public school teacher just doesn't have that freedom to tailor the program for each of the 30 kids in the class. Plus I know my child better, so I can more easily discern if a lack of achievement results from lack of motivation or lack of comprehension.
We are part of a support group, and our kids have many friends. We go on field trips, have meetings and monthly social activities, parties, etc. I don't believe that it's necessary to their social development to be in a classroom with 30 or so other youngsters all day, 5 days a week. Homeschooled kids on the whole are well-adjusted, confident, outgoing children. Sure, there are exceptions, but for the most part parents who choose to homeschool are actively seeking the very best for their children, just like the parents of public schooled children.
There are no absolutes in making choices for our kids. It would be so much easier if there were.
For our family, homeschooling is the right choice. We love it, and wouldn't choose anything else.
Erin