whey protein drinks vs. eating real food?

Newbie here again, I am new to the whole concept of a protein drink, but why do I want to drink my protein as opposed to eating it? I know body builders typically drink them, but why not just eat the protein? If I am trying to eat clean/healthy wouldn't I want it in it's most natural state? I know it's a lame and annoying question, but this is all new to me.
Thanks for your pateince.
 
There are no lame or annoying questions! Well, okay, there are, but that's not one of them.

That being said, I'm just here to say welcome and let someone more knowledgeable answer your non-lame and annoying question:)
 
It's not a stupid question at all. I was actually wondering the same thing. I'm reading a book right now that claims that many of us are already getting plenty if not more protein than we need in our regular diets. Even on a vegetarian diet, it's pretty easy to eat high protein foods and excel the daily recommended amounts. I've also read that too much protein contributes to heart disease and osteoporosis. So, I'm kind of on the fence about whether I think protein suppliments are necessary. Will be interesting to see the responses. I haven't made my mind up yet.
 
I am not the expert here but wanted to say I always try for nutrition in the natural form. it just seems right to me. Just my opinion.
 
Yes, if you are not a body builder or looking to gain muscle, you most likely get plenty of protein if you eat healthy, even without any animal products.

I believe that the emphasis on protein and calcium (from animals) stems from the amount of power the meat and dairy industries hold. Many doctors advise against consuming so much from animals and many also fervently disagree with our food pyramid.

Has anyone ever wondered why the US has such a high rate of osteoporosis, especially in women, yet we consume more calcium from milk than most places on the planet?

I am not saying protein is not important, but it should not be emphasized as much as it is, especially protein from animals. If anything, fiber and vitamin c should be, do to the gross lack of consumption of the two here in the US. Also, the idea that protein from natural sources is not "complete" is false.

With that said, if you want to build more muscle, you need more protein. While you can certainly get this by increasing the amount of clean foods you eat with high amounts of protein, such as broccoli and beans, it is often easier to consume a protein powder for several reasons.

I have recently, as in two days ago, decided to buy some whey protein powder. I have been using hemp protein (all natural, from hemp) for the past week, but it just tastes terrible, like grass. I have chosen two of the least refined brands, jay robbs and any whey. Yes, whey is from cow's milk, but this is one of the few animal products I consume per day (1 egg, 1 slice of no-antibiotic roast turkey (sometimes), and tuna in my salad, a great protein boost). I am very happy with my diet and have no problem using whey protein (I do have to cut out my ice cream, though:( ).

If you want to do some research of your own, a good place to start is the China Project. Another is Dr. Fhurman's Eat To Live, which is basically just a book of research that has been done over the years regarding the effects of foods on the human body.

Wow, this turned out rather long. So, long story short, if you don't want to build muscle, don't concern yourself with protein, just make sure you eat ALOT of fruits, veggies, legumes, and whole grains and make sure you get adequate amounts of vitamin B-12. If you do, just figure out what works best for you, be it more beans or a protein powder. Good luck!!!
 
i eat 6 meals a day. each of those meals has at least 20 grams of protein in them. i use the powder to make protein smoothies with fruit that way i'm getting some real food with it. it gives me another protein option for my day b/c i can only eat so much cottage cheese, egg whites, and chicken breasts. whole food is always your best choice but i find the powder a good add in with my busy schedule. Some people never eat the stuff and do just fine. Everyone is different so if you don't want to use it, don't use it. there is nothing magical about it. Oh and by the way, that was a great question. It gets confusing with all the info out there.
 
.
>
>I believe that the emphasis on protein and calcium (from
>animals) stems from the amount of power the meat and dairy
>industries hold. >
>Has anyone ever wondered why the US has such a high rate of
>osteoporosis, especially in women, yet we consume more calcium
>from milk than most places on the planet?
>

I sooooooo agree with this. It's incredible how we are programed to think certain things that are not true.
 
I think it's always best to get your nutrients from whole foods, which most protein drinks are not, but a smoothie (that contains protein, carbs and some fat) is a quick way to refuel after a workout (4 parts carbs to 1 part protein), or as a quick breakfast.

Some people drink protein shakes and eat protein bars because they are concerned that they might not be getting enough protein, but I think they often overestimate how much they really need.
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top