I've tried EVERYTHING and have never found anything that worked for me in the long run. In the end it always rubs off, ruins towels, pillow cases, sheets, puts brown rings around your shirt collars, etc... Famous Dave's made me break out in burning hives after using it for several weeks and it rubbed off on my FAVORITE Nike workout top. I just can't win. I'm determined to love my "paleness" now. I used to go to the tanning bed as well, but I've sworn that off too. It's not worth my health. I've heard bad things about the chemicals in those sunless tanners too.