Scary Warning for Weight Trainers

dani21496

Cathlete
I saw this on the Netscape homepage this morning. I guess I don't have to worry since I don't lift more than 50% of my body weight.

What do you guys think?
-----------------------------------------------------------

Scary Warning For Weight Trainers

If your exercise program includes weight training, pay attention to this: A physician from the Yale University School of Medicine has warned that weight training may trigger a brush with death as it can rip the aorta. Over a two-year period, Dr. John A. Elefteriades has noticed a pattern between weight training and this potentially fatal, but relatively rare heart ailment.

The Associated Press reports that Elefteriades has collected the cases of five patients who suffered an aortic dissection. Three were his own patients and survived. Two, who were not his patients, died. Of the five, two were doing weight training when the aortic dissection occurred, while two were doing push-ups and one was trying to move a heavy piece of granite. Elefteriades is quick to point out that five cases do not equal proof of a correlation, but he does think that all five patients were not able to tolerate the spikes in blood pressure that naturally occur from the strain of the activity. While a normal blood pressure would be 120 millimeters of mercury as the heart is beating, power lifters can get up to 370 or even 390. And he considers that risky, even if most power lifters do it without harm.

To that end, Elefteriades and his colleagues have published what they call a warning letter in the Journal of the American Medical Association. "The risk of weightlifting as a cause of aortic dissection has generally been underappreciated," it said. Two reasons: It's often misdiagnosed as a heart attack, and physicians don't really understand why the aorta weakens. He urges weight trainers to be cautious and limit the lift to no more than 50 percent of body weight.
 
I don't know anything about aortic dissection but I can tell you that people with mitrovalve regurgitation (& not everyone that has this VERY common ailment knows they have it) should not lift weights. So, while this article about 5 patients may seem "alarmist" it is something that people with cardiac conditions should be aware of.

That said, if you have a cardiac condition of any sort, you should ask your cardiologist if weight lifting should be left out of your exercise routine. BUT I doubt that what we lift using Cathe would be considered problematic!

EVERY workout tape has a "health warning" at the beginning & I truly believe it should be followed!
 
If there's any history of heart problems in the family, I'd sure think it was worth checking with your doctor, but I think the key words here are "power lifters."
 
If these guys were lifting like some of the people in Muscle and Fitness--holding breath, face turning all red and veins a bulging---I can see how they could have a heart problem. But push-ups?
 
Anyone can have an undiagnosed heart condition that could lead to a heart attack or sudden death. Think of all the young athletes who die while playing sports, and no one knew they had a heart condition. Any spike in blood pressure while lifting weights or doing any kind of hard physical activity can cause problems, especially in people over 40. That's why we aren't supposed to shovel snow. Don't forget to BREATHE while lifting!! Kathryn has a good point. Red faces and obvious signs of straining, holding your breathe, etc. are not things ANYONE should be striving for while lifting or doing any kind of physical activity. I'm not saying things can't still happen, but we all know we should be breathing during weight lifting. It will help prevent blood pressure spikes and the associated problems with it.

I take care of people at work a lot who find out they have heart conditions that were never diagnosed before. The truth is, unless there's a reason for one of us to have an echocardiogram or cardiac catheterization, any one of us could be walking around with a weak aortic wall and not know it. Especially anyone with uncontrolled, or undiagnosed, hypertension is more prone to having weak cardiac vessel walls. Diabetes (which can go undiagnosed in adults for years) can also play a part in this. Most dissections occur because of some sudden spike in blood pressure or other trauma, and it causes the aneurysm to rupture, but it can happen without any prior evidence of trauma. The aneurysm can literally be there for your entire life, and you wouldn't know it, and it wouldn't bother you unless something caused it to grow, or start leaking, or actually rupture.

Leslie, if in doubt about your murmur, ask you cardiologist please.

I hope this helps!!

Carol
:)
 
Ahhhh! But what a way to go. I hope I drop over doing something I love and I looooooove lifting weights. I just hope my husband buries my weights with me - I want to take them with me - he can keep all the money.


JoJo
 
>Ahhhh! But what a way to go. I hope I drop over doing
>something I love and I looooooove lifting weights. I just
>hope my husband buries my weights with me - I want to take
>them with me - he can keep all the money.
>
>
>JoJo


Too funny JoJo!!! LOL!! :7
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top