I saw it opening night with other Tolkien fans. I love the films--all of them. I was especially interested in the Two Towers because 1)I love the Ents and wish the episode with them was longer and closer to the book, and 2) I couldn't imagine how the book would be transformed into a film, because it is written in big narrative chunks (Jackson edited back and forth with incredible skill between the various narratives and characters), and 3) because I could never visualize the battle episode for the Rohirrim fortress and its retreating areas of barricade until I saw the film. But--sorry if I sound like a snob here--but the books are ultimately my preference, probably because there's just more--e.g., the romance between Eowyn and Faramir is severely curtailed and Aragorn proves he is the king by healing both of them. I also wanted the scouring of the shire (of Sauron and Wormtongue)at the end and I preferred the book's version of the battle with the Nazgul, Eowyn, and Merry over Theoden's body.And as for the Liv Tyler character--it ain't right. Any other Tolkien fans out there with opinions on the films??