No Non-diet Soda in Schools...

andtckrtoo

Cathlete
I was surprised no one had commented on this. I was curious to see what y'all thought about this:

http://www.usatoday.com/news/health/2006-05-03-soda-schools_x.htm

Beverage companies to stop selling non-diet soft drinks to schools




NEW YORK (AP) — School vending machines are about to lose their high-calorie fizz.
In a deal announced Wednesday by the William J. Clinton Foundation, the nation's largest beverage distributors agreed to stop selling non-diet soft drinks to most public schools, where childhood obesity has become an increasing concern.

"This is a bold step forward in the struggle to help 35 million young people lead healthier lives," former President Clinton said at a news conference. "This one policy can add years and years and years to the lives of a very large number of young people."

Public high schools would still be sold diet soft drinks under the agreement, but elementary and middle schools would be sold only unsweetened juice, low-fat milk and water, said Jay Carson, a spokesman for the former president.

"I don't think anyone should underestimate the influence this agreement will have," said Susan Neely, president and CEO of the American Beverage Association. "I think other people are going to want to follow this agreement because it just makes sense."

The agreement should reach an estimated 87% of the school drink market, Neely said. Industry giants Cadbury Schweppes PLC, Coca-Cola Co. and PepsiCo Inc. — all ABA members — agreed to the changes, she said.

The move shouldn't have much effect on the $63 billion beverage industry's bottom line, said John Sicher, editor and publisher of Beverage Digest, which compiles extensive data on the industry.

"The sale of sugar-carbonated sodas in schools is a tiny, tiny part of their overall volume," Sicher said. "The impact is more in terms of responsibility and accountability to the consumer."

The deal follows a wave of regulation by school districts and state legislatures to cut back on student consumption of soft drinks amid reports of rising childhood obesity rates. Soft drinks have been a particular target of those fighting obesity because of its caloric content and popularity among children.

"It's a bold and sweeping step that industry and childhood obesity advocates have decided to take together," Carson said.

Diana Garza, a spokeswoman for the Atlanta-based Coca-Cola Co., said "these voluntary guidelines escalate ... the shift to lower calorie, more nutritious beverages."

A man who answered the phone at Cadbury Schweppes' London headquarters said no one was available for comment. A call seeking comment from PepsiCo Inc. was not immediately returned.

"This is really the beginning of a major effort to modify childhood obesity at the level of the school systems," said Robert H. Eckel, president of the American Heart Association, which worked on the deal with The Alliance for a Healthier Generation and Clinton's foundation.

Under the agreement, high schools will still be sold low-calorie drinks that contain less than 10 calories per serving, as well as drinks that are considered nutritious, such as juice, sports drinks and low-fat milk. Whole milk will no longer be offered to any schools because of its calorie content, Neely said.

School sales of those kinds of drinks have been on the rise in recent years, while regular soda purchases by students have been falling, according to an ABA report released in December. But regular soda, averaging 150 calories per can, is still the most popular drink among students, accounting for 45% of beverages sold in schools in 2005, the report said.

The deal will be most easily enforced at vending machines, where students buy most of their drinks, Neely said.

How quickly the changes take hold will depend in part on individual school districts' willingness to alter their existing contracts, the alliance said. The companies agreed to work to implement the changes at 75% of the nation's public schools by the 2008-2009 school year, and at all public schools a year later.

Dozens of states have been considering legislation on school nutrition, and many school districts around the country have already begun to replace soda and candy in vending machines with healthier items.

The agreement follows an August decision by the American Beverage Association to adopt a policy limiting soft drinks in high schools to no more than 50% of the selections in vending machines. That recommendation was not binding.


Copyright 2006 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Posted 5/3/2006 12:47 AM ET
 
Oh, for crying out loud, why don't they just stop selling soda altogether? The fake sweetener stuff is just as bad, IMO.
 
I'm not clear on how this will really make a difference... I've never thought high school soda machines are to blame... but I guess every little bit helps... but what do they do in the afternoon after school??
 
I agree with you, too, Shelley. I don't allow my kids to consume artificial sweeteners and I don't think it should be an option to students.

Erica
 
I suppose it's a start.

My kids drink water, water, water, soy milk, 100% juices, water...put water and fruit juices only in the vending machines...what a healthy but never-will-happen idea.:)
 
My daughters will drink an occasional soda - occasional meaning once a week or less. They prefer fruit juice and water. My son (step son) drinks nothing but Pepsi and is 22 years old has 18 cavities and has to get a root canal (I'm 41 and have 1 cavity - no root canal ever!). When his sister stopped drinking as much soda, she went from having a cavity every check up to having none. My youngest (my only biological kid) has rarely had soda and has no cavities. Baring genetic influence, if that stuff rots teeth so badly, just think what it's doing to your insides! No thanks!
 
They need to offer kids options for healthy lunch. When I was in high school, every day I ate out of the vending machine..most of the other options were either non-vegetarian or high fat anyways. If my school had offered salad though, I would have gotten salad everyday.

I went to a private school, so my school wasn't really an indication of the nation's public school system, but I don't think soda is really the issue, healthy food options should be addressed first.
 
I have even used straight Coca Cola to clean the battery acid off the cables. Trust me it works. That in itself is too scary. I wonder what other sodas can do that? I'm glad I am working on cutting my soda intake out completely. I have been grabbing water or decaf tea lately. I went from 64 oz's a day of soda to 24 oz, and that's only if I decide to drive and get one.
 
Well, our hygenist told me that it isn't just the sugar in pop that is bad for the teeth...but the acid is just as bad. So, you can take the sugar out of the Pepsi can, but you still have the acid eating away at your teeth.

I don't think any vending machines belong in schools. We never had vending machines in the 60's-70's and we all survived. We had to drink water at school, imagine that?!?!

It is a purely financial issue with schools. They are making a profit off of those vending machines so they don't want to see them go anymore than the pop companies do. Hence the reason parents can't get them out of schools if the school board is all about $$$.
 
IMO if they are going to bother to make a change then they need to do it RIGHT and get rid of all sodas COMPLETELY.
 
>Oh, for crying out loud, why don't they just stop selling
>soda altogether? The fake sweetener stuff is just as bad,
>IMO.

Ditto!!

Robin
 
When my 11 year old was 6 years old, he came home from school and asked me, why do they teach us about eating healthy when they do not have healthy snacks at school?

What a great question for him to ask. It is pretty sad that a 6 year old noticed this but the adults did not.
 
Yeah, I have to agree that soda machines should not be in the schools....or as my hubby says, POP ;)


Live with sincerity, love with passion, and dance like you mean it.

Debbie
 
Elaine...I know what you're talking about. And then there are the days when you have multiple kids bringing birthday treats so your child is given two cupcakes to eat and juice to drink with them? Talk about a sugar over-dose. This just happened to my kindergartner again this week but we talked about this last fall...to only eat half of the cupcake and bring the rest home. She did do that the other day because not only did she have two cupcakes given to her but the teacher had made up candy sacks for the kids for May Basket Day. Ugh! And my dd said the cupcake she did eat was so sweet she didn't even like it so we just threw it all away directly from her school bag. But...think of the kids who ate all of that crap that day plus drank the orange juice. I am not a fan of juice being offered in schools either. Yes, because it's juice everyone thinks it's healthy...it practically digests immediately so drinking juice makes your blood sugar spike just like eating a candy bar. I try to encourage my kids to get a glass of water instead of drinking the orange juice but who knows how often they do that.

But anyway, so here my dd comes home from school with a stomach ache from eating the too sweet cupcake and some of the candy treats in the sack. What the heck is the matter with teachers'/schools. Why couldnt' they save two of those treats and hand them out the next two days...not all in the same day, the same 15 minutes. It just encourages bad eating habits.
 
>Oh, for crying out loud, why don't they just stop selling
>soda altogether? The fake sweetener stuff is just as bad,
>IMO.

I agree completely!

Neither sweetened nor unsweetened has any redeaming nutritional value: just chemicals, artificial color, flavor, etc.

I wish they would phase out junk food machines all together in schools, and replace the junk with healthier 'treats' like fresh fruit, nuts, some whole grain crackers.
 
>I don't think any vending machines belong in schools. We
>never had vending machines in the 60's-70's and we all
>survived. We had to drink water at school, imagine that?!?!

I remember when the very first vending machine came into my high school, when I was a senior. I was a member of the yearbook staff at the time, and they needed a 'model' to pretend to buy something out of the machine, so there's a picture of me in the yearbook at the vending machine (which I definitely would have bought things from at the time if I had the money, 'cuz I loved junk food back then!).

Unfortunately, the vending machines are a way for schools to get some income. Our university has them all over. There was even one put in the hallway across from my office (a Pepsi machine) until I rounded up my colleagues and had them sign a letter I drafted, complaining about the presence of the machine in what should be an area reserved for academics(most other machines are in starwells). They finally moved it...outside the entrance way!

One of the issues a student government presidential candidate brought up was bringing Coca cola products to campus (Pepsi won the bidding war several years ago). Unfortunately, a candidate who would propose replacing all soda and junk machines with healthy alternatives probably wouldn't get a lot of support.
 
>When my 11 year old was 6 years old, he came home from school
>and asked me, why do they teach us about eating healthy when
>they do not have healthy snacks at school?
>

As they say: "out of the mouths of babes."

It is a very hypocritical situation, IMO.
 
Also, it's pretty hard to get the schools to change without a lot of pressure from the parents. And since most parents probably eat and drink this stuff themselves, that's not going to happen.

If a rich parent "adopted" a school and paid them the amount they would get from vending machines, they might get rid of them. Kids would rebel, but they'd have to get used to it.

I've read of some schools (small, experimental schools) where junk food isn't allowed and there are no soda/candy machines. The instances of disruptive behavior decrease, and students do better academically.
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top