112toguru: Thanks for your post. I have TA's meta omni, mat, and PP. I've only done 1 week and then stopped because in my mind I just don't see how these can be effective. I've done cathe for years but i have to say I have a bit more muscle then I like. I wanted to know how your results compared with traditional weights vs TA workouts? Did you have a specific goal with TA or did you just decide to try her out?
I did Cathe workouts almost exclusively for over 2 years from beginner on. I experienced a bit of over-training (or something like it around Oct. 2010, probably just due for a lighter month, kept pushing) went to some barbell exercises from Rippetoe's book Starting Strength (which is awesome) then into a combination Cathe/Alaria rotation (Cathe's & Alaria's latest in December last year) I felt really efficient (with weights) during that month. I started a Gym Styles rotation in January 2011 and thought, I could increase weights, do more, etc. etc. but had a nagging suspicion that there were some others areas I needed to work on. (flexibility & balance)
Long Story:
I happened upon Tracy's 30-Day Method Book & with a gift card & discount, got it for pennies. I had only to glance through it a few times to find what I had been looking for for months. Bar type - mobility exercises, I didn't know at the time or before, what that was, but it was actually
mobility not
flexibility that was lacking in most of my fitness training.
Sure there are other extremely good benefits to Tracy's Method (you would need to stick with it for more than a week though):
1. Strength in Core, wrists, low back, inner thigh, outer thigh. (I would highly recommend TAM for this alone) You will get strong.
2. Balance & barre work, You could probably mix something up form Cathe's in the workout blender. Tracy's program the way it is, especially Meta has you balancing everyday. It is much more challenging than it looks, and will improve your balance quickly.
3. Focus, If you use her workouts you will increase you ability to focus & relax. Of all the things I needed was this ability to be able to focus on the task & relax different muscles in order to complete the workout as designed. I can not tell you how well this translates to running.
4. Cathe's traditional approach got me started, it taught me how to lift, and what I could get from it. It also showed me my weaknesses. I learned how the barbell could be great for women, for total body conditioning! and that it can be fun!
5. I really believe that as many different things I did over the past 2 years, starting with the Wii Fit & now running 3 miles 4 times per week, well it just wouldn't have happened without all of it.
How does Tracy's Method compare? I think what it does is complement Cathe's workouts, I think it gives you a different kind of strength & works an entirely different range of motion, in an (for the most part) entirely different way.
My goals were mobility (& flexibility with Tracy) and the weight loss was good too as well as toning, but those were secondary.
I just decided that I wasn't afraid of what anybody would say if I tried something different. Truthfully, Madonna was/is a pretty good spokes person, she is very fit, could really have any trainer she wanted, and has to be for her job, I just don't see how someone (not to mention all the other celebs) messes around when they have to get in shape & stay that way.
I took a chance on it, and it worked for me. I took a chance on Cathe too & that worked too. I took a chance on Kangoos, and running, and it's working. I look at it this way, these programs are tools in my tool box to keep me healthy, strong, & fit for years & years to come, at least I hope so.
Early on someone from Cathe's staff said "There are some things that Cathe does not do" I took that to mean, you're going to have to look elsewhere for some things that you may need to fill out your training. So I did. Cathe is the best at what she does, Tracy may be the best at what she does too.
HTH.
Sorry it took so long to reply, I've been, uh, running...
* Is this like my longest post ever? side note congrats Debbie H!