Just in case you thought the Grapefruit Diet was a good idea, think again!

morningstar

Cathlete
Grapefruit diet nearly costs woman her leg
Updated Thu. Apr. 2 2009 6:33 PM ET

CTV.ca News Staff

Who knew that eating grapefruit three days in a row could put you at risk of leg amputation?

A case report in this week's issue of The Lancet describes how a woman developed a blood clot in her leg that was worsened by a high intake of grapefruit.

Doctors at Providence St. Peter Hospital in Olympia, Washington, say the slightly overweight woman had begun an aggressive weight-loss diet that included grapefruit every morning.

Three days after starting the diet, she went on a relatively long car ride. The next day, she felt pain radiating down her lower back to her left ankle and noticed that her leg had turned purple. She went to hospital complaining of difficulty walking, shortness of breath, and light-headedness.

An ultrasound confirmed the woman had a large clot in the veins of her left leg, from the hip down to the calf.

Doctors decided she was in danger of losing her limb to venous gangrene, and immediately sent her to the hospital's interventional radiology department. There, she had clot-busting medication injected directly into the blockage, which dissolved it.

Even after the clot dissolved, doctors found she had chronic narrowing of the large vein in her hip, which can lead to formation of blood clots. They placed a stent in the vein to widen it and by the end of the day, the woman's leg was back to normal.

Although the woman's medical history was unremarkable, she was 42 and taking birth control pills. The pills contain a synthetic form of estrogen, which can cause an increased risk of blood clots, particularly in women over 35.

When they asked about her diet, they found that she had eaten grapefruit three days in a row.

That grapefruit played a role in her dangerous blood clot, the doctors now believe.

Grapefruit can block the action of a key enzyme that normally breaks down the form of estrogen in her contraceptive. In some people, eating a lot of grapefruit can lead to a increase in drug concentration, increasing any side effects those drugs might cause -- in this case, the clot risk posed by the birth control pills.

Health Canada has issued several warnings to remind Canadians that fresh grapefruit or grapefruit juice can increase, or less commonly, decrease, the effects of some drugs. The fruit contains bioflavonoids that appear to interfere with the metabolism of many drugs.

As little as one 250 ml glass of grapefruit juice can cause an increased blood drug level and the effects can last for three days or more.

The effects vary from one person to another, from one drug to another -- and even from one grapefruit juice preparation to another. This results in an unpredictable increase in blood drug level, which can cause serious effects.

Sour oranges, such as Seville, or tangelos, a hybrid of grapefruit, may also interfere with drugs, though most other citrus, such as lemons, limes, sweet oranges and tangerines are not thought to have this effect.

Because of the unpredictable effect of grapefruit, Health Canada advises Canadians to take the following precautions:

If you are taking medication for any of the conditions listed above, do not drink grapefruit juice or eat grapefruit in any form until you have talked to your doctor and your pharmacist about the potential for an adverse reaction.
Avoid taking any drug with grapefruit juice until you have talked to your doctor or pharmacist.
Read the labels on foods and natural health products to make sure they do not contain grapefruit or its juice, or Seville oranges.
Always report any adverse drug reaction to your doctor or pharmacist immediately.
The Florida Department of Citrus also issued a statement on Thursday, saying it will be reviewing the report.


"Based on information available to date, The Lancet report looks to be inconsistent with published scientific studies which indicate grapefruit does not cause a clinically significant interaction with oral contraceptives. We are aware of no validated evidence that grapefruit affects oral contraceptives, and they are generally considered to be safe to consume with grapefruit," the Department of Citrus said.


"The industry continues to work collaboratively with leading scientific experts on food-drug interactions to evaluate research on potential drug interactions with grapefruit."
 
I was eating a grapefruit every morning for 2nd breakfast for about 2 months, then I got tired of them. The last bag I bought is still sitting in the fridge. I've switched to oranges. But, I am not taking any medications. It sounds to me like the grapefruit reacted badly with the BC pills. Isn't there a whole list of medications that grapefruits react badly with?

Nan
 
My sister had a pulmonary embolism -- that is, a blood clot in her lung. She was on the birth control pill and spent an enormous amount of time sitting down commuting in a car. The doctor felt it was the pill and all the sitting that made it happen to her -- I think the pill definitely has to be part of the equation. If you're not on the pill, I wouldn't worry about it so much, but of course I'm not a dr. -- I only play on on the internet.....

my sister is fine, by the way....... it was scary for a while!

-Beth
 
Hmmh, I find it interesting that the grapefruit is blamed. Isn't it the birth control pill that caused the problem in the first place. Blood clots are a well known side effect of bcp, aren't they?

Instead of saying, geeh, maybe the pill is not such a good idea in some cases, it's the grapefruit. The medical community never ceases to amaze me.
 
Hmmh, I find it interesting that the grapefruit is blamed. Isn't it the birth control pill that caused the problem in the first place. Blood clots are a well known side effect of bcp, aren't they?

Instead of saying, geeh, maybe the pill is not such a good idea in some cases, it's the grapefruit. The medical community never ceases to amaze me.

My thoughts exactly Carola.
 
Instead of saying, geeh, maybe the pill is not such a good idea in some cases, it's the grapefruit. The medical community never ceases to amaze me.

I agree.

But the grapefruit growers don't spend a lot on advertising and have a huge lobby behind them.;)
 
I don't think the medical community is attacking grapefruit (and the media is KNOWN for creating all sorts of hysteria where truly NONE exists, and I kind of think it's the media who is stirring the pot ;)), I just think they are cautioning you that if YOU CHOOSE to take BCP, then you need to exercise care with certain foods. ;)
 
Carola I agree. The grapefruit did it! She only ate them 3 days in a row. It is not like she was consuming a dozen a day! I just was talking to a friend who has hi blood pressure, heart problem, hi cholestral etc. He is taking TWELVE pills a day and when he mentioned this to his doctor he was told not to complain some patients were taking THIRTY. What is that mixture of who knows what doing to your body and your mind is questionable. Who knows what interacts with what and in what way and they want to mention that a woman ate a grapefruit a day for 3 days and it almost cost her her leg?!
 
I absolutely agree that the media is creating a hysteria, Michele! I guess that's what sells papers these days.

That being said though, in my endeavors with doctors not only over the last few months I have found that for some (not all) in the medical community the focus is always on something else and not on the side effect of the drug.

To give you an example, I was talking to a conventional oncologist about chemotherapy. There is clear evidence that one of the drugs that they wanted to give me, adriamycin, causes heart toxicity. When asked about that he told me that it had little to do with the drug but as people age they get diabetes, get overweight and they drink alcohol, etc That's what causes the heart problems. REALLY????

He actually told me because I had been drinking alcohol in the past I probably had damaged my heart muscle and that would be the reason if I got heart problems, not the adriamycin. Hmmh, interesting view!

That's not an isolated incident, just an example. I have found that many doctors will blame anything else but the drug for side effects. I think this is a very troublesome path that we are walking because side effects for drugs are not reported and lead to very delayed measures like in the example of Vioxx.

In respect to the grapefruit, the article actually said you have to ingest large amounts of grapefruit for that effect. 250 ml of grapefruit juice is about 3 or 4 grapefruit, if she ate 1 grapefruit 3 days in a row, I really doubt this had an effect.

The woman had been taking birth control pill for a while according to this article. Why is it so astounding that she could get a blood clot from the pill, it's a well known side effect. The risk becomes even higher as we age, even according to the drug companies.

I guess my point is, the grapefruit in itself doesn't cause any problems, it doesn't cause blood clots, the pill can and does cause blood clots, with or without the grapefruit.

Does this make sense?
 
Last edited:
Let's see: slightly overweight (aka inactive, sitting too much), she went on a relatively long car ride (sitting for long periods is known to cause blood clots), 42 and taking birth control pills (the pill causes blot clots, especially for women over 35).

But it was the grapefruit. Of course.

Maybe the grapefruit exacerbated the problem, since it can make some meds stronger (maybe weaker too), but come on!

I just went off the pill (and I'm never going back on this time), and I'm sooooooo happy about it!

Amy
 
I don't think the medical community is attacking grapefruit (and the media is KNOWN for creating all sorts of hysteria where truly NONE exists, and I kind of think it's the media who is stirring the pot ;)), I just think they are cautioning you that if YOU CHOOSE to take BCP, then you need to exercise care with certain foods. ;)

I have to agree.
 
I believe eating grapefruit for certain people is dangerous. People taking high blood pressure meds. Also certain other meds., but not familar which other ones there are.

Also older people sitting at great lengths for instance an airplane/car... rides to a place that takes a lot of hours need to get up and stretch and or walk around, because it can cause bloodclots in the body.

Grapefruit is not for everyone, thats for sure, I found even with calcium I have to be careful taking grapefurit, because it makes my heart palpitate.

Janie
 
Thanks for the info -- I'm on the pill, 44 years old and love grapefruits! I just bought a big bag yesterday! I do a lot of sitting while working, but I'm definitely going to get up and move around more during the day!

Julie
 
yeah I don't think it was the fruit

Hmmh, I find it interesting that the grapefruit is blamed. Isn't it the birth control pill that caused the problem in the first place. Blood clots are a well known side effect of bcp, aren't they?

Instead of saying, geeh, maybe the pill is not such a good idea in some cases, it's the grapefruit. The medical community never ceases to amaze me.

Why implicate the fruit when bc is known to cause this? And btw I eat 1/2 a grapefruit every morning and my bc seems to be working fine. (for hormone control)
 
Grapefruit is a food that can have interactions with various drugs. So much so in fact that for many years now every hospital I've worked at strictly bans grapefruit and grapefruit juice from being served to patients. It's more the combo that's potentially dangerous not that grapefruit is damaging by itself. There's also a lot of drugs where there is no interaction.

Diana
 
Last edited:
"In some people, eating a lot of grapefruit can lead to a increase in drug concentration, increasing any side effects those drugs might cause -- in this case, the clot risk posed by the birth control pills.
"


I don't think that anyone in the article is disputing that it was the birth control pill that is mostly to blame for the clot -- it is saying that the grapefruit exacerbated the side effects that can be caused by the pill.

I was a faithful journalist for several years and must defend the media in this instance. No created hysteria here. It's simply a case report talking about what the doctors' findings were. Research has shown that grapefruits/grapefruit juice can magnify the side effects of some drugs. Ask any doc.
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top