foot problem - no cardio...

AnatW

Active Member
Hi,

I have been suffering from some pain in my foot, especially after a hard workout. My doctor suggested that I do not do any impact cardio for a while until my foot feels better. The only activity he suggested is swimming, but I don't belong to a swimming pool.

I would like to lose weight (25 lbs) and I was wondering what I can do (other than clean diet) to continue my weight loss ? Is doing weight training 3-4 time a week be enough ? will I lose my cardio endurance or the weight sessions can keep me at the same level ?

Thank you all,

Anat.
 
[font size="1" color="#FF0000"]LAST EDITED ON Aug-21-02 AT 09:21AM (Est)[/font][p]There is a post I think in 'ask cathe' the title is something like no cardio its about a weight rotation with no cardio. Its fairly recent and my help you and my be just what you need.

Babs
 
Hi Anat,

I can tell you from personal experience it doesn't have to be "that bad" although you think it is because we equate weight loss with cardio, so the idea of no cardio freaks us out!
But last October 2001 I injured my foot during step and instead of stopping/modifying, I kept going and made it worse, and in the end I had to take several weeks off impact altogether, and I'll share with you exactly what I did, and still lost weight during the 4 weeks.
Weeks 1-2, yoga (m-w-f) and strength training (t-th-sat)
Weeks 3-4, yoga (m & f), low impact cardio (w), strength training (t-th-sat)
at the time I only had PowerHour and MIS for strength training, so those are the two I rotated each week for 4 weeks, and I still lost weight during that month, and was pleasantly surprised that it didn't hurt my weight loss efforts at all.
Good luck and take care of that foot :)

Donna
 
Hi, Anat,
Did your doc give you any indication as to what the foot problem was? I treat a variety of foot problems on a regular basis, the most common one by far in athletic populations being plantar fasciitis.

What kind of symptoms are you having?
Maribeth
 
Hi, Anat, I can relate! I have been laid up with foot pain and a pronounced limp for too many weeks this summer. I am seeing a podiatrist next week.

My left arch collapsed a few years back from too much running. My feet were not designed for high impact but I love high impact. I saw a podatrist and got custom orthotics and they were wonderful.

Have you seen a podiatrist or looked into orthotics? There are some very excellent over the counter orthotics available also.

I have a bad habit of running around barefoot and I know that part of my problem stems from that. So, until my appointment I am wearing shoes with my orthotics in them and it is already helping.

The collapse of my arch caused pulling on that part of the heel that the plantar facsia is connected to and I have a heel spur. There is a surgical procedure but orthotics and caution during exercise work well too.

My advice, see a foot expert. As Maribeth pointed out, there are many things that could be wrong with your foot and you need the specific cause. When my arch collapsed, my PCP said no more running but after I got my orthotics, I had a great year of racing and completed the Tucson Marathon in December of 1999. I did 35 miles per week then tapered off and got heavily into Cathe but the orthotics really helped!

My foot has deteriorated but that may be because I haven't been making sure it was supported. I'll be forty in December so you see I am too young to give up this wonderful high intensity exercise!

Hang in there and pester your doctor for the right care! You'll be doing cardio in no time. Keep strength training too. Can you get access to a stationary bike or elliptical trainer?



Bobbi http://www.plaudersmilies.de/chicken.gif Chick's Rule!
 
Hey Anat,
You do not have to do high impact cardio to lose weight. Could you do some low impact cardio in addition to your weight training?? I lost a lot of fat while doing mostly low impact cardio. I'd be happy to send you a list of vids that I have discovered are good low impact workouts.
Also, the yoga that someone else on the thread mentioned is a very good suggestion as something to integrate into your week.

:)
Kathy
 
Do you have acess to a bike or stationary bike? I suffered from Plantar Fascitis and bone spurs and the only way to get ride of the inflamation/pain was to eliminate impact. I found a bike to be very helpful at keeping my cardio up during that time.

Take time to enjoy those who matter most to you & do all things in moderation :)
 
Hi Anat:

I had to give up impact activities for about 7 months while dealing with a very stubborn case of plantar fasciitis(PF) in my left foot. It started out mild, but eventually got so bad that I could barely walk.

Before the PF stopped me, I used to do almost exclusively step and running for my cardio. I thought I would go nuts when I had to stop. But there is good news! The injury ended up bringing some new activities into my fitness life that I now love. I started going to the gym and taking indoor cycling (spinning) classes. These are usually 45-minutes long and feature lots of interval work plus provide some resistance training for your legs. I bought some good padded shorts and, later on, some cycling shoes. (Because of my PF, my feet are sensitive to the pedal pressure. Cycling shoes are very stiff and provide excellent protection.)

I also started swimming and pool-running once or twice a week at my local community rec center. I thought I would be bored by the water activities, but I ended up really enjoying them. I went in the morning and swam in the lap lanes and watched my 7-year old son and lots of other kids taking swim lessons. It was very entertaining.

I also was able to do the elliptical trainer at the gym. This simulates running, without the impact. I found that it still sometimes aggravated my PF, so I had to limit the length of my elliptical sessions. But it provided excellent crosstraining.

You never realize how much you depend on strong, healthy pain-free feet until you have a foot that is injured. I hope that you will follow your doctor's advice.

Following is a long aside, but I've learned the hard way, so I'll share. If you have PF, it's really important to ice religiously, stretch your foot before you get out of bed, address the biomechanical issues that caused the PF (this usually means getting prescription orthotics, but sometimes over-the-counter ones will suffice.) Also, wear good shoes with good arch support. If you're doing everything right (as I was) and it's still not improving, it could be that you've developed a lot of scar tissue. Find a doctor, physical therapist or chiropractor that can do ultrasound and cross-fascia massage. And do these treatments 3 times per week. This will help immeasurably and fast! Don't be freaked out if your dr tells you that you have a heel spur. Those are not a big deal and they can be reabsorbed. The cause of the pain is not the spur, it is the inflamed fascia. Treat the inflammation, get rid of the cause, get rid of the scar tissue and go forward.

Whoo. I'm tired from typing. I'm also afraid that I'm beginning to develop a foot fetish or something ... never thought I'd get so passionate about foot issues.
 
WOW - Thank you ! I didn't think I would get so many replies...

I am not sure what is the definition of my foot problem (I live in Israel and I only know the term in Hebrew). I can say that the pain is mostly in my big toe (not nail) and in the arch. It is getting a bit better now, but it seems to keep coming back after an impact aerobic session. I tried using the elliptical, but that bothers me as well.
The problem is that I took a break from sports for 4 weeks now and as a result I didn't feel like eating clean and now I probably gained some weight back. Why is it all or nothing with me ???
I think I will focus on the non-impact activities, perhaps try to find a pool nearby, and eat clean - that should do the trick. It's all a matter of willpower.

Thanks again !!!!

Anat.
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top