Exercising more, but gaining a size?!

sunsdaughter

Cathlete
I've recently begun exercising more...adding on more running plus Cathe's weights and step aerobics...and I've noticed that my clothes are actually fitting tighter than usual! Has anyone else had this happen to them? I'm thinking it may have to do with the muscle I'm gaining...I build muscle super easily. My eating hasn't really changed.
Any thoughts?
 
Thank you for posting this. I also have the same problem. I have gained 10 pounds in the last two years.

-Christina
 
Maybe your body is telling you that you are overtraining, and not getting enough rest.

Far too many people fall into the "the only better is MORE" when it comes to a fitness schedule and program. You may want to re-evaluate not only what you are doing but how often and for what duration.

That being said, if what you have gained is muscle, that's all to the good.

A-Jock
 
I have been steadily exercising since 1999 (21 workouts a week). Over four years I gained ten pounds, but at the same time I got stronger and my endurance increased - but my clothes got tighter, too. It wasn't a disgusting weight gain either so I felt really good and I kept doing what I was doing.

This year, all for a sudden (an average drop of 1.25 lbs a month), I dropped those ten pounds and I am seeing definition! The hard work will pay off eventually. Just hang in there.
 
This is my experience. I've worked out regularly since 1997. (I'm 28 now)
This summer (2003) I took a month and a half off of working out(cathe dvds: mostly cardio). I went to Mexico City for two weeks and then went home to Canada for 4 weeks. The most exercise I did was some walking with my dad everyday (1 1/2 hours) for 2 of those 6 weeks. When I came back to Texas I noticed my pants fit a lot better and were actually loose on me. I got on the scale and realized I had lost 10 pounds in those 6 weeks of not working out. I was surprised because I expected to gain weight during my vacations. (I'm 5'7 and went from 130lbs to 120lbs in those 6 weeks).
It couldn't have been too much muscle loss because the only weights I had included in my training before I left on vacation was Cathe's Cardio and Weights 2x per week. The rest was all Cardio.

So....I don't know how to explain it. It's been 3 1/2 months since my vacation and I haven't gained any of the weight back. But since being back from vacation I have been doing more weights and less cardio. ie: more circuit training, PUB, Leaner Legs type work-outs.

Janna
 
I really think cardio is important, but not as much as weight training. I think these are all classic symptoms of over training. Rest more, workout less (cardio), lift heavy (as is possible) and eat well. I do cardio, but not loads, and only low intensity...i look better today with less cardio than when i was teaching 24 class (cardio) per week. I was flat. Now i have more muscle, look leaner and like my body better.
 
Thanks/What's your workout schedule?

Thanks for all of your input! :)

I'm so used to thinking that if I want to lose inches, I have to do 5-6 days per week of cardio. (I've been running about 30 minutes 3-4 days a week, doing Cathe step tapes 2-3 days a week, and weight train with Cathe 2-3 days a week.) I've never really thought about decreasing my cardio...maybe I'll try it.

It sounds like a lot of you have had success with doing more weight training and cutting back on cardio. What kind of workout schedules do you have?
 
I had this happen to me too. I worked out A LOT. I ate in a way that seemed very sensible about 1800-1900 calories a day and mostly low fat. I gained every year until this spring when I found http://www.physiquetransformation.com/home.htm

This is a site that is run by body builders that have complete knowledge of how to reduce body fat while retaining muscle.

They even these body builders say that diet is 80% of how you look and only 20% is exercise.

Their tool is quite inexpensive, just under $8 a month. You don't have to buy anything else from them. You select your own foods and eat them in the ratio of protein, carbs and fats that the program determines will produce optimal fat loss for you. They have a wonderful supportive yahoo group that quickly helps newcomers with any questions or problems. http://health.groups.yahoo.com/group/pfasupport/
There are other Cathe fans that use this site. Cathe's wonderful exercise are a great complement to this program which mainly focuses on food.

When I only did Cathe workouts (many, many more each week than I do now), I only gained fat! I have lost many, many inches of fat on this plan and it is great to combine with Cathe's wonderful exercises.

Dona
 
For those who have had the weight gain, I'm right there with you -- this happened to me, and I haven't been able to shed the extra 10 pounds I GAINED after resuming weight workouts 3 years ago.

For those who have cut back on cardio, and increased their weight training, could you please give an example of your exercise routine?? I would be greatly interested in looking at that . . .

I am a pear shape, and so I don't know if my body "type" means that I should exercise in a certain manner -- I know that everyone's body is different, but I don't know if I need more cardio, more weights, or an even balance between the two -- would really appreciate some further info.

Thanks!
 
Ok, you are singing my song. Lost weight back in 99' by simply cutting all of my food portions in half. I have cut out all fast food, all Italian food, Mexican food,sweets (eat chocolate maybe every 2 or 3 months) and stick to mostly fish, eggwhites, chicken,naturally low in fat cheeses, and lots and lots of veggies. I continue to eat this way on a daily basis, never ever finishing a full restaurant portion. I have never been horribly over weight, typically in the 10-15lb range. I have worked out consistantly since 1992, always incorporating weights and cardio. I started gaining in 2001 and have kept the 15 pounds on ever since (and let me just say, the belly hanging to my knees and the oversize J-Lo type butt isn't muscle). I have gone the "less cardio, more heavy lifting" route, the "addition of more calories" route, "adding more cardio, less weights" route, and now I am doing Firm tapes for the next couple of weeks to hopefully "shock" my system a little bit after coming off of an S&H rotation. I can't get my weight to budge an ounce. I am thinking it must be my age catching up to me. I turned 38 this year and think the "40" weight gain has started early with me. It is very frustrating. It seems I try so hard for so little results. My co-workers make fun of me (in a good way) because I don't touch the sweets, bagels, chips, etc. that they will bring in for the whole crew to eat. Not a single one of them works out, they eat fast food everyday (while I am eating my homeade salads) and they don't have weight issues like I do. I guess this falls into the category of self-acceptance. Would be nice to see results after all the hard work though.
 
I wonder what Cathe would say...

It sounds like we're all kind of in the same boat.
I know that muscle weighs more than fat, but it just seems weird that my clothes (especially pants) would fit tighter after incorporating more and varied workouts. My body type is somewhere between Cedie's and Brenda's...

I would love to hear what Cathe would say about this...do you think she'll respond to this thread?

Thanks for all of your input!!!:)
 
RE: I wonder what Cathe would say...

Hi,
I actually posted this question at videofitness last year, i didn't get a solid answer. For years I was pretty thin (about 100 pounds0 5 feet tall and did all aerobics. After a few years of adding weights my weight went up to 108-110, clothes were tighter but i saw more definition and looked better. I finally concluded that even though muscle takes up less room than fat, I had gotten bigger since I had little fat to lose. If you think about it, muscle takes up more room and weighs more than nonmuscle. Does this make sense to anyone else?
 
I change up my weight training every month. I'll do Slow & Heavy but instead of working the tapes the way Cathe has it designed I'll couple my chest w/biceps, back w/triceps & abs, shoulders w/abs & legs w/abs. Abs are changed up every time too between pilates style/traditional & stability ball. I'll slip into my week an interval or circuit tape & a kickboxing tape. After a month of this, I switch to endurance type of training increasing my cardio, the next month I'll switch again to Pure Strength tapes doing these tapes exactly the way Cathe designed them EXCEPT I tack on 2 more sets per exercise. Then I rethink my rotation again & go into doing the Pyramids but now that I have those Body Blast tapes I stole }( Carol's rotation for coupling the Intensity series w/Body Blast. Cathe also had a great idea to couple your chest work using CTX & then follow it up w/Power Hour!!! Oh was that a frier!!!! I never plateau & I also have a lot of variety which you can see from what I described above. If you need any more help, just let me know. Best, Kathy:D
 
Hi DB1! I would strongly recommend you look at the site physiquetransformation.com. Bodybuilders know a GREAT deal about nutrition & this site is owned by 2 bodybuilders. They'll help you figure out what you should be eating to lose. HTH, Kathy
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top