Any American Idol groupies here :)
- Thread starter midwestchick
- Start date
Tess_ATL
Cathlete
My favorites were Brook, Michael and Carly. I think they will be in the top 3. I felt bad for David A. also because I was really looking forward to him after his Imagine performance. I definitely think this season is one of the best, it is harder to choose favorites. I think Sayisha and Kristy will go home.
>> I
>>do think that the sniping was a bit much yesterday.
>
>It definitely seemed to go beyond 'playful', especially
>between Simon and Ryan.
>
>> As much
>>as Simon can be rude, his opinions are usually spot on.
>Paula
>>and Randy say the same thing over and over with no good
>>constructive criticism.
>
>I agree. I usually agree with Simon. With Paula ("you look
>beautiful tonight") and Randy ("dawg!", "dude!"), I sometimes
>can't figure out what they are trying to say. And, as you say,
>they don't often give much constructive criticism that the
>contestants can use to improve. ("I'm not feelin' it" doesn't
>help much, does it?)
I agree as well. Simon, though blasted for his remarks all the time, actually knows what he is talking about. Paula when saying how "pretty" they look, doesn't give the singers anything to hang on to in regards to improving their performance, which is what it is all about, isn't it? (run on sentence) And what is really up with all the bad vibes, rude remarks, etc. between Simon and Ryan? I don't get it. Did you see where Ryan was saying something in Simon's ear and Simon said, "No, I'm not going to do that! NO!" This banter is very annoying and irritating to me. It is like listening to a bad joke and not being in on the punch line. It seems to me that Ryan is the one that eggs things on. GRRR
I think Kristy should go. That was the worst rendition of Eight Days A Week I have ever heard. But she probably had a cold, or it was the band's fault, or the new set made her nervous. Certainly, it wasn't her fault. :-( I am anxiously awaiting her departure.
>>do think that the sniping was a bit much yesterday.
>
>It definitely seemed to go beyond 'playful', especially
>between Simon and Ryan.
>
>> As much
>>as Simon can be rude, his opinions are usually spot on.
>Paula
>>and Randy say the same thing over and over with no good
>>constructive criticism.
>
>I agree. I usually agree with Simon. With Paula ("you look
>beautiful tonight") and Randy ("dawg!", "dude!"), I sometimes
>can't figure out what they are trying to say. And, as you say,
>they don't often give much constructive criticism that the
>contestants can use to improve. ("I'm not feelin' it" doesn't
>help much, does it?)
I agree as well. Simon, though blasted for his remarks all the time, actually knows what he is talking about. Paula when saying how "pretty" they look, doesn't give the singers anything to hang on to in regards to improving their performance, which is what it is all about, isn't it? (run on sentence) And what is really up with all the bad vibes, rude remarks, etc. between Simon and Ryan? I don't get it. Did you see where Ryan was saying something in Simon's ear and Simon said, "No, I'm not going to do that! NO!" This banter is very annoying and irritating to me. It is like listening to a bad joke and not being in on the punch line. It seems to me that Ryan is the one that eggs things on. GRRR
I think Kristy should go. That was the worst rendition of Eight Days A Week I have ever heard. But she probably had a cold, or it was the band's fault, or the new set made her nervous. Certainly, it wasn't her fault. :-( I am anxiously awaiting her departure.
