> I
>do think that the sniping was a bit much yesterday.
It definitely seemed to go beyond 'playful', especially between Simon and Ryan.
> As much
>as Simon can be rude, his opinions are usually spot on. Paula
>and Randy say the same thing over and over with no good
>constructive criticism.
I agree. I usually agree with Simon. With Paula ("you look beautiful tonight") and Randy ("dawg!", "dude!"), I sometimes can't figure out what they are trying to say. And, as you say, they don't often give much constructive criticism that the contestants can use to improve. ("I'm not feelin' it" doesn't help much, does it?)