American Idol

S

sarab

Cathlete
Well, who were your favorites of the girls last night? I can honestly say that I don't care much for the girls. I think they are kind of boring. Then again, everybody kind of sucks compared to Chris.....

But, if I must pick a favorite, I would say it would be a tie between Katherine and the dumb, little southern girl...what is her name???? Oh, Kelly. Although, I don't really like how she trembles her voice. She does it a lot. It gets on my nerves!

Okay Chris, I am waiting for you tonight!!! I might just be speaking for every American when I say that!

Sara

http://www.picturetrail.com/saraburnham1
 
Hi Sara,

I'm also a huge Chris fan...I love the rockers! So I can't wait until tonight.
I'm not impressed with the girls either. The young ones (Paris and Lisa) are good, but just too young. My favorite girl would have to be Mandisa, but I don't think she will win. Kelly cracks me up, but you're right, her voice is just not up to par.

Go Chris!!:D :D :D

Becky
 
I also like Katherine alot and Kelly, well I am not at all sick of her, to me she is very refreshing and just makes me smile...:)...I like her voice and she is way cute, but we all have our opinions! I have yet to watch the guys...so I will check out Chris...:)...Carole
 
Sara,

I agree. I am for a few of the guys...well, mostly Chris, but Kelly Pickler is pulling at my heartstrings because of what she has already been thru with her family and she does have a nice voice, but not sure it will be good enough. I did like Katharine last night. Mostly it was boring for me.

Charlotte~~
 
I also find Kellie refreshing! She is so honest and there is no pretense about her whatsoever, I love that. The young girls, Paris and Lisa, are so OLD, though, don't you think? They choose these songs that are just so dull and don't represent their youth at all, and it seems like they are wasting their talent. I love Katherine and Mandisa's voices A LOT, but I really think that a guy is going to win. I get so bored on the girl's nights. And Chris just rocks doesn't he? I am waiting tonight to see if Taylor will cut out his "woo!" s. I really like him, but that got really annoying.

Missy
 
I love Kelly, what you see is what you get with her, she doesn't try to act like anyone but herself. Don't know if she'll win, but she does make me smile.:) Kathryn was great last night as well as Mandisa. For the guys, Chris hands down! :7
 
My favorites of the girls are Mandisa and Kathryn. Is it just me or does it seem like Kelly may be "acting" a little ditsier than she actually is??? It's just a vibe I get...kind of like Jessica Simpson...smarter than she actually lets on because she knows it sells?? I could be completely wrong, but like I said...just a vibe I'm getting. She does make me laugh though. The two young girls...Paris and Lisa...not a fan of theirs at all. Paris' voice really gets on my nerves for some reason, and well Lisa I just don't think she has what it takes voice wise.

The guys are so much better this season than the girls. My favorites are Chris and Elliott (Elliott's actually from my home town :D ). I think Chris is going to walk away with it in the end...he's got the whole package.

Deni
 
I thought Mandisa was great last night! I also like Katherine and Kelly. At first I liked Lisa and Paris but I didn't think they were as good the past few weeks. Another Chris fan too! I will be glad when the men and women are all together. It will be earsier than to find my favorite.
 
I really liked Mandisa, Katherine and Kelly.

I think it's time for Kinnick to go. As the second one to leave, it's a harder pick, but I'd go with the one who sang the "Heart" song.

I like Kelly's voice, but she always has a scared look in her eyes when she looks at the camera. It's getting better, but it's almost like she's pulling back from the camera, and her gaze doesn't go through to the audience. Anybody know what I mean?

I think the tremble in her voice isn't vibrato, but another manifestation of her stage fright. She also seemed to go off key just a bit when the camera was straight on her.
 
> At first I liked Lisa and Paris but I
>didn't think they were as good the past few weeks.

I agree! They seemed to dull down a bit from the beginning.
 
I agree that Katharine and Mandisa were the best last night. I also like Kelly. I don't think she'll win because she doesn't have the best voice out of the girls but she is very sweet and has a good enough voice to move along.

I look for Kinnik to go and maybe Melissa. For some reason Melissa doesn't get much attention. I think she's pretty good but I don't think she'll go all the way.

Looking forward to the guys tonight. I think Chris will be the next idol. He's got real talent.
 
Oh gosh I better get my workout in before american idol! I can't wait to see Chris. Even liked seeing him last night.

Can't wait to see him.
 
I thought Mandissa had the best performance of the night. She couldn't have picked a better song for herself. I also really liked Katharine, Kellie and Melissa. I think Melissa will be going home this week because she hasn't been given as much attention on the show that the other girls have. That's unfortunate because I really like her. I usually like Paris but I couldn't remember why when she sang that conga song. Lisa and Ayla are both good but they're also both robotic and sing boring songs. Kinnik is blah. She was totally off last night.

Kristy

I solemnly swear that I am up to no good
 
I will be sad if Melissa goes. I don't think that she is the best singer, but I love the tone of her voice. It has the three S's: smoky, sultry and sexy. I would listen to her cd. She has chosen the best songs, too, I think along with Mandisa. They fit her. I can't wait to see the guys!

Missy
 
So what did you think of tonight? Paula was driving me nuts. I think that is why Simon was so negative.

I still like Chris the best. Maybe not the most exciting song tonight but he has what it takes. Simon was too harsh. Eliot sounded pretty good too. Ace is too much of a pretty boy for me. I bet Kevin gets voted off. What do you think?
 
I pretty much agree with you Robyn. I think Chris is the best overall at singing and performing. I think Elliott probably has the best voice, but tonight wasn't great for him.

I really liked Taylor, although his "moves" are just funny! Ace pulled off a pretty good performance tonight. At first when I heard he was going to sing a Michael Jackson song I thought, "OH NO! Big mistake!" But, he did a great job. I think he's as cute as he can be. If he makes good song choices, he'll be a contender all the way to the end.

Those are my top 4. Everybody else is pretty mediocre in my opinion. I predict Kevin and Will will be voted off next.
 
My faves are Taylor, Chris and Elliot. For the girls, I like Mandisa and Katherine. However, I like watching the guys more this season; they're more interesting and have more presence
.
 
Chris gave me goosebumps when he sang Seether. Forget what Simon said, I just think Simon is jealous!

Ace made me fornicate in my head. LOL!

Amish Yamin really can sing too.

Kevin I can't take too seriously as he looks like a 5th grader or something.

Taylor has got some dorky moves, but I bet he is super fun to hang out with!

Will just doesn't have what it takes. Picking all the wrong songs, but has a great voice too.

Gedeon is such a sweetheart and a gentle soul!

I like Bucky's voice. He should stick with country though.

And what is up with that big white flowery bow that Paula was wearing. I think it was there for all the guys to take note of her cleavage. :9

Charlotte~~
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top