>I am afraid that some children (especially boys who are
>typically more active than girls) are diagnosed with ADHD just
>because they have a hard time sitting in a classroom and so
>they act out. Some people aren't meant to sit that long (it's
>not their best way to learn) or they may have a learning
>disability and this is their defense mechanism to disguising
>the problem without even realizing what they're doing.
Nancy, you are so right. A Montessori teacher told me, "Your son has ADHD and should be on Ritalin." I didn't see how a non-medical professional could make a diagnosis just from observing my kid's behavior in only one kind of dynamic for such a short time, but I said, "I've read so many books on ADHD but my son doesn't fit the profile." She looked at me with this very insulting expression, as if saying, "You're his mom. Of course, you're in denial." I wanted to punch her lights out. We got our son tested and found out he has SI dysfunction, a disorder of the nervous system that has symptoms very similar to ADHD, but which requires a very different treatment.
Having said that, Shelley, I think it's important for you to find a therapist you are comfortable with and is WILLING to be your partner, instead of a professional peering down on you from on high (because I have met some of those). I believe testing is important. My boy could've been just diagnosed with ADHD just based on his behavior at home and in school, but testing proved I was right. He didn't have ADHD, but he needed help just the same. Maybe it's not ADHD, maybe it only LOOKS like it. And if testing proves it IS, then you go from there.
Here's a book I wish I still had. I read it from cover to cover in a day when I thought Andrew had ADHD and I was desperate for help. But I'd sold it so I could buy the books on SI dysfunction that I needed.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0684801280/102-2538909-8510546?v=glance&n=283155&s=books&v=glance
It's the best book I've read so far. Both authors themselves have ADD. It's a very optimistic book. It shows you that people with ADD or ADHD CAN have lives, and very successful ones at that. Even those who never had early intervention.
If you need to talk about therapy, what to expect, and things like that, you know where to reach me.
HUGS,
Pinky