Women and Weights--times are changing

elsie3

Cathlete
I'm so glad that the attitudes about women and weight training are shifting. There are still some old prejudices out there, but it's encouraging to see that many people are more informed about the benefits that weight training provides. I love seeing studies and articles touting the many health benefits of strength training and other forms of exercise for women.

My mother was born in 1930, and I fought her endlessly on this topic. No matter what I said or what evidence I gave to support my views, she always held that "muscle turns to fat" and "women will bulk-up" and that it wasn't "feminine." I just gave up, because her ideas about what women should look and act like were not only nauseating, but definitely not me.:mad: Her ideal of feminine beauty was thin, frail, helpless, and stupid (and blonde--no offense to blondes intended). And the only acceptable forms of exercise for a female were walking, tennis, and golf. We don't have this conversation any more, because she has dementia and doesn't even know who I am. But she once gave herself a double hernia (requiring surgery) by trying to lift something without help. And she had to have knee surgery because she would only walk and not do any other cross-training exercise to strengthen supporting muscles.

My Mother-in-Law is a decade younger, but holds similar views. She is a sweet woman and I love her very much. I know she doesn't like the idea of weight training, but she has tact enough to not say anything. She has had osteoporosis for years. And her husband just had back surgery and can't lift anything, so she is practically helpless in that regard. She was so concerned for me because I carried a 5-gallon jug of water down to the cellar in their cabin.:eek: She was so afraid that I would hurt my back or something. I didn't tell her what kind of weight I can lift, but I'm glad that I can!

Go Catheletes!
 
I love this topic! I can SO relate to everything you are saying. With the exception of my hubby and a few others in my life, weight training is just not vastly done or accepted within my circle of family/friends. If you are not on a cardio machine or
walking/running/jogging, you are wasting your time lifting weights and building lean muscle mass. The prejudice is still there -- alive and kicking :(.

Whenever I have my family/friends over and they sneak a peak at my equipment (which includes a Turbo Tower, barbell, and several heavy weights), they look and me and ask "you can lift that ??" or "how come you don't look like Arnold Schwarzenegger?". I just do this :rolleyes: and don't even try to explain anymore. I will happily continue on my merry way, enjoying my lifting burn, lean muscle mass and speedy metabolism ;).

On a happy note, my DH says that there are many seniors at his gym in the weight room :).

Great topic!

Natasha
 
Views on lifting weight

Glad you posted this thread.

In my opinion, People are so opinionated about weight lifting are more likely in lack of acknowledging the benefits. If they knew, they would not be so against it.

Although views are changing, there is still a lot of room for improvement in terms of stigma attached. There are still people who think you have got to be taking toxic harmful substances/drugs to build muscles!

How many of us lifting weight have been told in a joke "No one can mess about with you" ? It does not happen often but still does! Fitness enthusiasts do not aim at intimidating people by lifting weight.

So far I am not having any negative comments from my family! Neither am i being encouraged to challenge myself further. My mother is not around and does not have a clue on how active I am...She is just worried that I may be shrinking too much. My family know I have come such a long way. My mother in her early sixties never been active at all.

What are your thoughts Cathletes?
 
Last edited:
My grandmother (born in 1908) used to exercise with "Indian Clubs" in her bedroom while my mom and aunt watched from the bed back in the 1930s. She had shapely arms and a nice figure. Gramma also did Scottish sword dancing and ballet barre work and had beautiful legs well into her 80s. My mother does not like to exercise and was never active (other than a brief period of Jitterbugging) in her life. She has horrible osteoporosis with fractures in her spine and terrible pain. Gramma set a wonderful example, but for some reason Mom never was interested in "getting a glow". She is amazed that I can workout (and enjoy it) with the intensity of a Cathe workout. It is beyond her comprehension that I want to build muscle and sweat. When I see her all stooped over I feel such remorse for her that she didn't have the information and tools available to her that I do.:(
 
Great topic - I think my mom regrets not working out like I do. She is 70 now and has always walked and biked, but no weights. She didn't believe in it because that just wasn't done in her generation. But she didn't mind me taking weight class for my gym rotation in high school. I was one of two girls in that class and had a blast.

My girlfriends now still don't understand why I would rather be in the weight room than doing cardio with them. Since I didn't see a lot of women in the weight room, I stopped going and then found Cathe!

It was funny when I helped one friend move, I helped her boyfriend lift the heavy stuff and she would bring pillows down and huff and puff. I love that I am strong and hope that I will always be this way :) So glad that there are other women who feel the same!
 
I'm so lucky, my Mom is so cool. When she saw that I was taking up weight lifting, she said, "Good, you need to have some muscle." :eek:
 
My mom is only in her early 60s and she's very supportive and proud of my weightlifting and other workout habits. She is definitely the one who inspired me to start exercising. She has worked out to Kathy Smith videos for as long as I can remember and frequently goes hiking or on long, fast walks. She has also started doing some of The Firm's workouts in the last three or so years. I just wish she would add some weightlifting to her routine. I think the heaviest dumbbells she owns are 5lbs. I've tried to encourage her to do a little more, but she says that she does enough already and there's no way she could do a Cathe workout. Maybe she's right that she's okay, she was an occupational therapist and knows her way around the human body, and is in way better health than 90% of her peers, but I still worry about her bones as she gets older. She's a tiny thing and I want her bones to stay strong! What do you guys think, leave her be or continue to encourage her to lift more weights?
 
I'd leave her be.

My mother has moved her whole life long but has never "exercised" for the sake of it and would scoff at the combination of her name and fitness in the same sentence!

She has spent her whole life "doing" things, constantly active, rarely ever sitting down until the end of the day. According to recent research, this is actually an ideal way to be. She has always maintained high NEAT (non exercise activity thermogenesis or something like that!) levels that have kept her healthy and free of disease her whole life until she was 78 and finally had to have the heart surgery that all her 5 siblings had before the age of 50 (genetic predisposition towards cardiac disease).

She has raised 6 kids, without the benefit of an automatic washing machine for the early years (!) and gardened her whole life long (digging, weeding, lifting, pulling, hauling wheel barrows of debris around, etc), has gone on multiple walking holidays every year, and eaten and drunk in moderation. She is a living, text book case to prove that moderation and high levels of activity can reduce incidence of disease (even if genetically inherited predisposition exists).

She takes medication to ward off osteoporosis. She has never dieted her whole life long. She's about to turn 80, now she spends all her time looking after my father who suffers from vascular dementia. She never stops.

I wouldn't dream of suggesting weight training to her. It wouldn't mean anything to her and, like your mother, she already has established her preferred activities that bring her both health and happiness, when she now gets the time to engage in them.

Seriously, if she has any spare time at all, forget dumbbells: she'd rather watch "Downton Abbey"!

Clare
 
wow, this video is awesome! No kidding about reverse the aging process. These ladies are impressive and they look fantastic.
 
Fit at any age

That is a LOT of hard work and dedication. Wow! How cool.... a mom & daughter team. That's so awesome. :cool: Yes, lifting weights is a very important component in a fitness regimen. I am so anxious to have my tennis elbow surgery over with so that I can get back to MY regularly scheduled fitness program!! :mad:
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top