Vlad has run of the house. He's just over a year old and is a Shepard/Rott mix. We tried to keep him in the kitchen when we got him (he was 13 wks old) but he quickly climbed over the gate and out (about 2 days) He house broke FAST (less than a week), so we let him have run of the hous.e We keep the bedrooms/bathroom/basement closed, so he just has access to the kitchen and living room. He's a chewer, so we have to make sure anything that isn't supposed to be eaten is put away and his toys are left out. He does go on the couch, which he knows he's not supposed too, but hey, if no one is home to see. He doesn't even try it if we are home. We've not had any major issues, except he did eat the remote once and that was $15 to replace. But hey, we left it out, duh!
My previous dog Spyro, also had run of the house. We kept him in a cage when we were gone for the 1st year and half or so, and he never liked to be crated, he fought it all the time. You hear dogs consider crates to be their den, but he didn't like it. Then our house got broken into. And the dog was in the cage. Um, yeah, the dog is supposed to protect the house, but he is in a cage?!?!?!
Growing up, the dogs always had free run of the house, too. That's my vote.
Nan