When do you tell your kids....

gidget1978

Cathlete
about Santa? I have a 9 yr old(soon to be 10) and she is asking if Santa is real this year.Although, she asked last year but just brushed it off.This year she ask almost everyday and I am starting to feel bad about lying to her.I think she knows the difference b/c of school and her cousins don't beleive in Santa.I think deep down she knows he isn't real.
Should I just tell her the truth now or drag it out for another year? And HOW do I tell her? What did you ladies do, who have already dealt with this.
Lori:)
 
I don't think my mom ever sat me down and told me there was no Santa. I think I just kind of figured it out for myself. Of course, I'm crazy as a loon and probably in need of deep psychotherapy--LOL!!!

Michele
 
>I don't think my mom ever sat me down and told me there was
>no Santa. I think I just kind of figured it out for myself. Of
>course, I'm crazy as a loon and probably in need of deep
>psychotherapy--LOL!!!
>

Awww Michele, you might be a bit crazy (who isn't, right?) but you are certainly not a loon and you can get all of the therapy you need right here on this forum! ;) lol
 
I think that when they start asking is the time to tell them. My DS is 7 and he knows that Santa isn't real although we still pretend. When he was in kindergarten, his best friend who is a Jehovah's Witness told him Santa wasn't real. DS asked me and I said "What do you think?" He said "I think he's real." I said, "OK" and that was the end of the discussion. But then at Easter he wanted to know if the Easter Bunny was real. We had the same discussion but when I said "OK", he said, "But Mom is the Easter Bunny really real?" So I told him. We talked about the spirit of Christmas and how pretending to have Santa, Easter Bunny, etc was part of making the holidays fun and special for kids. We talked about not saying anything to other kids because parents like to tell kids themselves when they're ready. I also told him that Santa doesn't come to see you if you don't believe. Ever since then we have pretended that Santa, the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy are all real. He does a very good job of pretending. If I didn't know for sure that he knows, I would think that he really still believes in Santa.

Hope this helps...
 
>>I don't think my mom ever sat me down and told me there was
>>no Santa. I think I just kind of figured it out for myself.
>Of
>>course, I'm crazy as a loon and probably in need of deep
>>psychotherapy--LOL!!!
>>
>
>Awww Michele, you might be a bit crazy (who isn't, right?) but
>you are certainly not a loon and you can get all of the
>therapy you need right here on this forum! ;) lol


Gee, thanks Wendy. You may regret that when I hound you for your phone # so I can call you and whine--LOL!

Michele
 
This does help.Thanks. I am going to mention it to DH and see what he thinks.She already says that she doesn't think that he is real and then I keep lying to her.Its not like she is 3 and I am still going to get a few more years in.She is 9 and I think we are getting down to the final crunch.
If DH says that it is o.k, the next time she ask, I will tell her.But I will explain it the way you mentioned.
I don't think she ever thought the easter bunny was real.She thought the tooth fairy was until she found her tooth in the house!
Lori:)
 
I honestly think my DD has been pretending for the sake of DH and I for a couple of years now...She "isn't sure" (in her words) if he's real or not, but in the same breath, flips her hair (I know, I know...Diva in the making) and said, "I MUST believe, or I won't get any presents"...Those little twinkly blue eyes goin' the whole time...Maybe she was sent by Santa to keep my family in the Christmas spirit??

MJ
 
Hrad to say when my kids stopped believing, I never really told them, I did my oldest at about 14, I think like someone said, at school no one believes in santa and they talk about finding their gifts, plus my kids found them one year, so the only one who believes in santa is my 6 year old, And as long as he still has that magic, I am not going to take that away from him just yet, I think if he askes I might tell him,
 
WOW Lori, I'm so glad you started this thread my DS is 9 and I'm thinking he's starting to wonder about Santa, too. I'm not sure how to handle some of the questions and comments he makes, but there are some awesome suggestions here. He also thoroughly believes in the GRINCH!!! He sets traps for him every year and trys to catch him before he steals his presents from under the tree. :7 I've kept that alive, too, whether that was a good idea I'm not sure. But, I was afraid that he would stop believing in Santa if I told him the truth about the Grinch.

Good luck.

Marcia.
 
>>>I don't think my mom ever sat me down and told me there
>was
>>>no Santa. I think I just kind of figured it out for myself.
>>Of
>>>course, I'm crazy as a loon and probably in need of deep
>>>psychotherapy--LOL!!!
>>>
>>
>>Awww Michele, you might be a bit crazy (who isn't, right?)
>but
>>you are certainly not a loon and you can get all of the
>>therapy you need right here on this forum! ;) lol
>
>
>Gee, thanks Wendy. You may regret that when I hound you for
>your phone # so I can call you and whine--LOL!
>
>Michele
>

LOL Michele! Call me any time!:)
 
>Holy crap, he's not real??????
>
>
>

LMAO Super Debbie!!! But really - he's not real?!?!?!?!? Say it ain't so! I can still hear the bells ring! HE HAS TO BE REAL!
 
HAHAH You guys are funny.

Hey Lori, I don't know exactly what the right age is but I know my parents had to tell me by the time I was 8 or 9 because there are just too many other kids in their schools who know. She will continue to ask about it.
 
Hey, Lori. Without reading other's resposes I can tell you what I did. When Mariah starts asking me questions, I always ask her "Well, what do you think?" I did the same with Santa. She told me he wasn't real, and I asked her why she thought that. Since she is used to me having her make up her own mind, she had a list all ready for me:
A) Reindeer don't fly, they don't have wings to help them (you really can't argue with that, now can you?)
B) It is against the law to go into someone's house without them knowing (I still laugh about this one!!!)
C) He is too fat to fit down our chimney (true......)
D) There is no way he could get all around the world in ONE night, mom!!!

How cute is that? So, with all the evidence before us, I asked her what she thought, what she really believed in her heart and with her gut. She said "There is no such thing as Santa, you made him up." I didn't lie to her because I feel like that would be wrong. I asked her how that made her feel, and all she could think about was getting to go shop for her brothers now!!! :p I did, however, tell her the TRUE story of a guy they call St. Nicholos who devoted his life to helping and giving to the poor, and we continue to remember his thoughtfulness by giving gifts each year. Over time he became Santa, then Santa Claus. So she knows that we didn't just make him up, but that there is meaning behind Santa as well as Christmas. :)

HTH
Missy
 
>When Mariah starts asking me questions, I always
>ask her "Well, what do you think?" I did the same with Santa.

Missy, that's exactly what I do. Wow, now I feel better knowing I'm on the right track.:)

Andrew just asked me if Santa's real. He thinks all the Santas at the mall are "fake", and that if there were a "real" Santa, he can't possibly fit through our chimney, and "Why does he have to go through the chimney, Mama, when he can go through the front door... but then our alarm might go off and the police will come and get Santa!" He also thinks elves only belong in books. Ergo, if elves aren't real, Santa can't possibly have any help. And who can make so many toys for every child in the world all by himself?

I just let him ramble on to let him see for himself where his thoughts would go. He's only 5. I thought I'd deal with this much later.

Like when he asked if God is real. He was only 3 when he asked me that. A year later, he asked where God lives and what's his address.

Last weekend, he asked me if angels are real. I asked him what he thought and he said he doesn't think so because he can't see them. And besides, who goes flapping around in wings?

He doesn't believe in the Easter Bunny. He is, however, still pondering on the possibility of the Tooth Fairy being real.

Sigh. Sometimes I worry if he's going to need even more therapy when he's an adult. I think he WANTS to believe in Santa because those gifts have to come from someone, somewhere, you know... and he's so much into the concept of opposites these days. If there are so many fake Santas running around out there, there must be a real one that these fake Santas are "imitating". Yep, his word, not mine.

Pinky
 
Missy, my dear, you truly are an old soul:) Your method for dealing with the Santa issue is truly inspired. I'll be taking notes for when Sophie starts asking.;)
 
>I don't think my mom ever sat me down and told me there was
>no Santa. I think I just kind of figured it out for myself.

Same here. I don't remember anyone ever telling me there was no Santa. At some point, I just "knew."
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top