Muscle confusion

ReneePruitt

Cathlete
Hi can some tell me.. If we get swelling with lifting and it will subside, but How does it sunside if we do the constant confusion.
Im new to lifting really. But what i read is to lose weigt gain muscle u have to have muscle confusion.

But then i read some people gained water weight or when you start lifting u may have inflamation and it will go away. But i am at now asking ... How will the imflamation subside if your are constantly confusing your muscles.? And i know from a medical standpoint and getting older..inflamation that is constant anywhere in the body isnt good.
So what? The body gets " used" to the confusion for everyone eventualy?
 
Im hoping not to irritate anyone, hoping someone can answer this. I think it is a question that i need in order to understand the weight lifting and muscle repair process. I thought noone saw it.
 
Last edited:
Have you tried doing a search on the articles on Cathe.com? I know there have been many articles about weight lifting and the process. If you have XTRAIN, the User Guide has great info about the weight lifting process.

Hope that helps. :)
 
Yes i have but i didnt see anything about the inflamation. I hear people say u get swelled when u lift and that is normal, it will supside but my question is how will it subside if u are confusing the muscles ? I may not be explaining myself right. But medicaly any inflamation that wont go away can be bad for all body systems... So i see it is fine for when u lift but if u are lifting and constantly changing up the reutine to cause muscle confusion, wouldnt that keep ur body in an inflamatory state, and will effect, somehow negitivly on the other systems of the body.
Deep i know... but i know i have seen RA is a process of inflamation and eating away bone but building in the wrong area. An auto immunity.
I know also Doctors DO NOT know in some cases weather inflamation is a symptom, or a cause of other things that seem, or rather can SEEM totaly unrelated. Idk im thinking alot. But i was thinking yrs ago about the hormones that are injected in meat, it effects girls to speed up process of pubity and in turn can accelerate sertain diseases. And as it turns out, i wasnt wrong. So if i am thinking to much im just intriqued by the body and the processes that it goes through. Lol
 
Last edited:
There is a difference between muscle inflammation and water retention/swelling. Inflammtion refers to injury/healing process and swelling is when the muscle absorbs more water. Two completely different things and two completely different reasons why it happens.

Long and short- you get water retention when you begin to weight train (new to it or coming back) because it's something "new". The muscle breaks down and during the repair process, water is absorbed into the muscles. I don't know the full process as I'm not an anatomy major, but most water retention from these activities is gone within 3 weeks; at about that time the body begins to adapt to these new stresses on the body. If you were doing power lifting constantly then you'd have chronic retention because you are constantly subjecting the body to more and more weight and powerful bursts. When you change up the routine you are asking the body to perform the exercises in a different sequence perhaps different reps and even switching out a couple of the exercises. You never stop training the body only train it differently. Bc the body isn't used to the "switch" it requires the muscles to adapt which is how you get DOMS. You can still get water retention but it isn't as great nor does it last as long again, because you never stopped training, only changed how you trained.

Inflammation is an injury- think arthritis, pulled muscle, twisted ankle, torn tendon, tenditits (anything ending in "itis" is referring to inflammation). This is due to an injury or even a build up of scar tissue that causes the soft tissues to swell from damage. Blood rushes to the injury, not water. This is to get oxygen to the damaged tissue to help in the healing process. This is the type of "swelling" that leads to medical issues and periods of time off and recovery- even surgery.

Things like RA and other auto-immune disorders are a chronic inflammation. I have FMS so it doesn't take anything these days to cause joint swelling and flu-like symptoms. I had to give up step workouts for that reason. In these cases it is important to listen to the body and not lift heavy weights. Heavy weights can aggrivate already inlfammation-prone joints and soft tissues. The chronic inflammation can lead to bone and joint breakdown like you stated and thus causing long-term consequences from anything to limited mobility to joint replacement and everything in between. You don't want to add fuel to the fire with auto-immune issues. This is why so many RA Doctors stress walking and swimming as your mainstays in exercise because they reduce the stress hormones which cause inflammation (moderate to vigerous exercise actually causes cortisol increases- a stress hormone). Strength training should be light to moderate with light to moderate weights or use bands/tubing and body weight. The idea is to stay functionally fit and strong, being able to work around the yard and house, play with the kids, lift your kids and boxes, and so forth- not to be a fitness competitor or body builder. Those activities will make your RA, FMS, and other conditions much worse and dibilitating.

This is a nut shell hopefully helps to answer some of your questions.
 
Wow! Thank you! I just read ths! I didnt know you made a post! Wonderful wonderful explaination., now i understand better. It sounded good at first abput muscle breaking down til someone mentioned inflamation and i remember mom had RA and two i remember in medical assisting school they said inflamation was a sign something is wrong. Of course that,was a few yrs ago so i dont remember everything and i work in a dental office as dental assistant still so cant keep up with medical if u dont deal with it everyday. So i really appriciate you taking ur time to talk to me about this. I am happily lifting moderate to heavy (for me). Im not as sore this week as last week. I dont think im swelling anymore. Lol
I too get almost parinoid since i saw mom pass away with complications of RA.. So i just keep watching listening to my body go slow and continue to get stronger and more flexable everyday. I want the quaility of my life to be good for as long as can. I dont have RA as far as they know ( had blood test) course that doesnt mean 100% sure. So far osteo in knees and that can be better if i can get some weight off. So really you are ALWAYS so helpful! If i could give ya a hug i would lol. { { hug }} !
 
thanks for asking the question, renee, and thanks for your wonderful response, mrsprincess! i was actually wondering the same thing:)
 
Well thanks Katied lol i was thinking maybe i think to much. Glad to hear someone else was thinking what i thunk lol.
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top