I wouldn't really know how to compare the two since all Cathe Live workouts are not the same. There are 54 Cathe Live workouts now and they all are different and vary in intensity, length, and style. If you're asking are there some or several Cathe Live workouts that are similar in intensity to ICE? - I would say yes, but until you actually see the actual workouts words and descriptions can only give you a broad and vague perspective of what the new workouts will really be like.