Hi LFleming,
Two years ago I had a breast reduction with a lift (went from a 34DD to a 38C). I had the anchor incision, the one that goes under the cup of the breast. If you can, please try on any bra in the store first, as I found some sat right on my incisions and were bothersome. Not sure about your incisions, but wanted to bring it up. And I had professionals measure me for several months as things 'settled'.
I found the Victoria's Secret Knockout Front Close sports bra to work for me very well. It is a bra within a bra. The inner layer is a molded cup that you click to close and then (just in the front) a second layer that zips up over it. I use this for all of my high impact since my surgery. Very minimal if any bounce, and zero pain.
BTW, I know my surgeon also recommended that I wear a bra during the night (forever). I use stretchy yoga bras for this.
Also, make sure when you try on to jump up and down in the fitting room to imitate a workout and check the bounce and feel.