America Idol 04/18/2006

createdbygod

createdbygod

Cathlete
So what did ya'll think about tonight's performance?

Whew. I don't know who to want to win anymore! Lately, I haven't really like Paris, but I REALLY liked her tonight. I loved Katherine as well! I liked Chris even tonight (he's not my favorite in general). I still like Kelly and her personality (I know many find it annoying), but she didn't do too hot tonight. ahhhh... so hard to narrow it down! If I had to choose the bottom 3 (not just from tonight's performence) it would be Kelly *tear*, Eliot, and Chris.
 
I think they all did a decent job tonight with the exception of Kelly. I'm really sick of her and Ace. I LOVED Kelly's dress, though. LOL! :p

Based on tonight's performances, though, I suppose I'd choose Kelly to go.
 
I thought Katherine was really really good. The bottom 3 I would say is Kelly, Ace and my dear Eliott. It was a great show though. I thought Paris and Taylor were really good too. I did not think that Chris was that great. He was okay, but I thought there were a lot of people that did better than him. We shall see. It should be interesting. I thought Rod Steward was adorable.

Susan
 
Bye, bye Kelly. I HOPE she goes. She's just too raw for the competition. I tried to vote for Taylor but could not get through.

"It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt." Mark Twain ;-)
 
I think it was a very good show. I did not get to watch until after voting on DVR.

Chris was really good. It showed he has a voice, not just a rocker(although I love the rocker).

Paris has such a great voice for this, dressed a little severe, but she was good.

Taylor was a bit boring at first and then did OK.

Kellie - looked very nice, but I just don't like her nasal voice, yuck, she won't go home.

Elliott - good voice as always, I think it is his stage presence or something, but this guy can really sing on the money.

Ace - usually I dislike him a lot, but he was well above Kellie, actually looked nice, and he won me over a bit when he was genuinely happy about Simon's comments. So best performance of the season from him.

Kat - well, normally she leaves me cold, but boy was she good, and she is absolutely breathtakingly beautiful.

Good show tonight, Kellie should go home, but won't but I am hoping she will at least visit the bottom, Ace will probably go, and unfortunately, Elliott may visit the bottom again.
 
I only watched minor pieces (I worked out really late), but I did catch Rod LEERING at Katherine at the piano, lol. My SO was like, well, maybe he is looking for wife #10. Hehe.

I also caught the comments at the end of Kellie's song. Has anyone else noticed that when Paula has nothing to say, she makes a big deal out of what they're wearing?? I have never been able to figure out why she was chosen as a judge...

Marie
 
I think they all did a good job last night as well, with the exception of Kellie and her off-key, nasal, twangy singing. It's her time to go, I think. And that comment about "you helped me get a weight off my chest." This girl is not just naive, she's dumb! I do think she could have a career as a comedian, though.

I think the bottom three will be Kellie (who should go), Ace and Elliot (even though Elliot was good).
 
Great night, great songs! Kellie may have to pay tonight for her bad song choice, which was one of the most difficult of the night. I think she will be in the bottom, but overall I think Elliott needs to go tonight, it is getting painfully obvious that he is just not in the same league as Katherine, Chris, Paris and Taylor. Ace could go also, but I think he had a decent outing, which could save him.

Bottom Three - Kellie, Elliott, Ace

Any one of these could go, imo.

I am not a huge Rod Stewart fan, but I think he was the best coach of the year so far, based upon the finished product last night.
 
I think a bunch of them did well last night. It is getting harder to determine who was "the best" because they are all good...except Kelly, Ace, and Elliot. It is time for them to go! I still want Chris to win. Although, I think he is too good for this AI. He is in another class!
I voted for Chris!!!
Sara
http://www.picturetrail.com/saraburnham1
 
Did not like Ace's new look...EW! He sang well last night. I thought he did good.

Elliott also did very well. He is really growing on me. Like his style. Also very nice guy!

Katharine did very well. She is so pretty too.

Kelly was not good and she is starting to get on my nerves. I am beginning to think she is fake?

Paris was very good. I agree with Simon though as she does sound like mini mouse when she speaks....beautiful girl and beautiful voice though when she sings.

Chris is always the bomb in my book. I want him to win!!!!! I just love his voice no matter what he sings!!!!

Taylor was boring earlier on, but spiced things up. So it was o.k.

I think Kelly, Taylor and Ace will be in the bottom three. JMHO.

ETA: Rod Stewart doesn't look bad for his age...compared to Kenny Rogers last week...GEEZ!!! Paula Abdul loves to show off her cleavage doesn't she? I thought them things were gonna roll out of that dress of hers onto the table. I was like..."oh, please don't"!!!!! LOL!

Charlotte~~
 
I think Kellie looks the way she does probably due to her being so young and genetics. I doubt she works out. JMHO. My DD is the same way.

Charlotte~~
 
>Paula Abdul loves to show off
>her cleavage doesn't she? I thought them things were gonna
>roll out of that dress of hers onto the table. I was
>like..."oh, please don't"!!!!! LOL!

It's rather hard not to notice. And it looks strange, too, with that gap at the top, then the major boobage down below. I think it's rather pathetic in a way. She can be very beautiful, but I think the 'look at my boobs!" outfits are trying too hard.
 
She's really not smart enough to be a comedian. I don't find what she does funny at all - just pathetic and embarrassing.

"It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt." Mark Twain ;-)
 
Oh my, where did Paula get those melons? I am sorry, but that girl needs a serious stylist, she just looks as spacey as she behaves..!:+
 
I have to agree, cause she is young and active. Gosh I think people are a bit harsh on her after all she is still a teen, my son is her age for a few more months, I like her and want to protect her.

I think with kelly, you get what you see, I don't think she puts on an act, I just think she's a country bumpkin so to speak.

Rhonda
 
Too bad - she'll be back! Bye, Bye Ace - big surprise that Chris was in the bottom 3!!!! I think Taylor's pretty safe, even tho' I couldn't get through to vote.

"It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt." Mark Twain ;-)
 
Well, to be honest, I think the show "rigs" what happens on kick someone off night because it took me dang near the 2 hours to get through to vote for Chris last night( and I voted 10 times for him!) , and another person I work with disclosed to me today that she voted for Chris 25 times!! LOL You know, they did this a few weeks ago and shocked everyone with Katherine being in the bottom 3 and yet it took forever to vote for her too! Go figure. I don't know, I think some of the show's stuff is rigged for the drama of it all, but in my opinion it won't matter if Chris gets booted because that man is surely going to get a contract from someone regardless!! Just my thoughts.......

Thomasina :7
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top