Treadmill or Elliptical Trainer?

[PennStater]

I'm seriously thinking about buying one of the two. I love the elliptical, but I suspect the treadmill is more versatile for home use.

I no longer belong to a gym, where I used both machines. And an Arc Trainer is too expensive, so it's not a consideration ;-)

I'm pregnant, so looking for indoor exercise options for this winter and for postnatal workouts.

Thoughts? Suggestions? Any input would be appreciated.

Thanks.
Allison

 

[acatalina]

I prefer the treadmill.
My feet get numb on the elipitical.
At least the treadmill i can control more.
I can have an easier one or really go for it.
I can elevate or not.
I have both. I hathe the elipitical.
Good luck on your baby.
Anne

http://www.picturetrail.com/gallery/view?p=999&gid=8227804&uid=3969941

 

[jdoll]

i vote treadmill there is more versatility and it takes up so little space!


jes

 

[lisaannjam]

Gosh, I really love both but totally understand that only one is an option. If it were me, I would go with a really nice treadmill. I think you'll have more versatility in the long run...haha

Congratulations on your pregnancy...Good luck and take good care.

 

[Elln]

As much as I hate the Elliptical, you do burn more calories on it than on a Treadmill (that is if you don't run on the treadmill) AND it's much less stress on your knees. Also, if you get one with the movable arms, you also get an upper body workout as well. For example, when I do 50 mins. on the Elliptical, I burn 625 calories and clock 5 miles; When I do 1 HOUR on the Treadmill (intense walking/incline), I burn 475 calories and clock 4 miles.

Good luck with whatever you buy.

Elln