I used to have the Reebok step and used it for years. There are things about both steps that I like. I do think the Club step is more versatile, though. I am short (5'3") and found that the Reebok step was just a little too short for me to put my feet up on while using it as a bench. I did like that it was all one piece, but eventually, I wore out the holes and the pieces would fall out when I carried it. I think the extra length in the Club step length also makes me work a little harder on the lateral movements. Plus, you can use the risers for the high step. But the Reebok is totally fine if that's what you have now.