Well, I must have deleted my before 4DS faux P90X rotation. I can't find it. Maybe Marcy still has it, we worked on it together. Sorry
I didn't like P90X, but I also was coming from a different place than most people. I have never been overweight in my life, I'm a size 2 or 4 already, and I already eat clean. My goals were definition, not weight loss. And I was looking to get stronger.
Here is what I didn't like about P90X:
* Cathe weight work is harder the way it is put together- also, for me, her leg work was better! (I danced ballet/jazz for years, so it wasn't the lack of weight work for legs, just the work itself was not good)
* Cathe cardio is harder/more fun/ better--because I was doing the Imax's and kickbox cardio, plyo X was not hard at all!
* I was lifting just as much with Cathe. The difference is Cathe works each muscle to failure, and Tony never does the same muscle more than 2X in a row.
* Cathe's warm ups are much better!
* Cathe's ab work was better for me- the X ab work was hard, but I saw better results with Cathe
* and last but not least---ENOUGH with the push ups!!! I can do about 40+ standard pushups and push ups are not hard for me-- I do "boy" pushups on my toes. Well, by the time I was at #25ish and I still had 15 more to go, I just lost interest. The only push up I couldn't do more than 30 was the dive bomber (i think 23 was my max) I just wasn't interested in doing all those push ups!! boring boring boring!
* I also didn't like when Tony would say "speed is your friend" when doing pushups or tri. excersises without weights. Speed is not your friend-- good form should be! Momentum should not be what is helping you get the next rep, your muscles should be working to get the next rep with good form!!
In fairness I should say what I liked about the X:
* I liked Tony, I thought he was funny
* I liked the challenge of chin ups and pullups
* since I tried this before 4DS, I liked the push/pull method, and the way the muscles groups were grouped together to workout. (i.e. chest/back; shoulders,tri,bi; chest, shoulders, tri; back and bi) but now in 4DS Cathe has those in a premix and reg. workouts
For me, for some reason, I could do the same Cathe dvds for 3 weeks and not get bored, they are still fun and challenging. With Tony, by week 2, I knew his jokes and I was starting to get bored. I also think I was excited to "do the X!!" there has been/is so much on these boards about it, it was exciting. But once I actually got into it, it wasn't so great. I think P90X is good for learning to stick with a rotation. To learn that you can go heavy and to challenge yourself (if you don't for some reason already do that with Cathe)
JMO,
Deanie