JT--------------------
UGH!
When I think of the word 'dating', that's my response. "UGH"! lol
I used a dating service for about a month, about 2.5 years ago. I dated a great guy for almost 2 years before breaking up with him. He was a great guy, and it turns out I actually KNEW him when I saw his profile on the site. I wouldn't have known he was 'in the market for dating' had I not seen him on the site. The overall experience was great, and we're still friends today, as are our kids.
For me, the dating service helped to put me out there, because it's not something I can or DO do in person (if that makes sense). What I'm trying to say......in everyday life, the circles I travel in all revolve around school and kids' activities. If a single gentleman sees me there, I think he would automatically assume I'm married; maybe that's stereotypical, but that's how I think it works. There is no way of him knowing that I'm single and PERHAPS interested in dating. Does that make sense? So for ME, the dating services are kind of my personal advertising service.
Recently............................
After a very recent and very BAD breakup, I realized I am sooooooooooooooo not ready to date again (DH will be gone 6 years this September, and I've had 3 'serious' relationships since then). HOWEVER, on a whim and at a recommendation of a very good friend, I signed up for the free membership at okcupid.com, about 2 months ago. I loaded some VERY basic info and NO photos of myself. IMMEDIATELY, I got several hits. Like you, I prefer to do a bit of chit-chat (preferrable emails first, then maybe a few phone calls) before actually meeting up. Problem with THAT, however, is you really can't tell if the person is being sincere or just blowing smoke. I was emailing with one guy, who, after about 2 weeks of emails, said he wants to get together instead of emailing or even CALLING me. Ummmmmm......I chose NO. Personally, NO. At that point, when he suggested the face-to-face date, I realized that I'm just not ready.
Sorry to be long-winded......in a nutshell, I think there is NOTHING wrong with the dating services, as long as you are TRUE TO YOURSELF and do what YOU ARE COMFY with. Good luck........I find it FUN to date as an adult, but it's hard GETTING that first date (for me, anyway).