No Magic Bullet

H

honeybunch

Guest
It's not how much you eat. It's WHAT you eat. Women who are not overweight but who indulge in a high-fat, high-sugar diet filled with empty calories are the ones who are most likely to become overweight in later years, according to new research from the Boston University School of Public Health in Massachusetts.

"The truth is that people are still confused about how their dietary behavior contributes to health risk," lead study author Dr. Paula A. Quatromoni told Reuters. "And people are frustrated with the controversy that exists, with arguments even among nutrition experts as to whether it's the amount of fat or the type of fat that matters most; whether high-carbohydrate diets are good for you; whether low-fat diets are appropriate either." Can current dietary patterns among women of normal weight predict whether they will become overweight? That is the question Quatromoni wanted to answer when she studied 737 non-overweight women over a 12-year period. In the end, 29 percent of the women became overweight. Based on this, Quatromoni determined that women who are "junk food junkies" are 40 percent more likely to become overweight than those who eat a heart-healthy diet rich in fruits and vegetables and low-fat, high-fiber foods. Those whose weight fluctuated due to yo-yo dieting had a slightly higher risk of being overweight. The takeaway: Eat a balanced diet and exercise. The study was published in the September issue of the Journal of the American Dietetic Association.
 
Oh, how comforting Honeybunch. But for some reason I just don't feel any better about eating three servings of veggie whole wheat pasta....:):) Thanks for the article..

Janice
 
It's easy to do if you have a weekly pig out day like me. I can take restrictions for 6 days per week real easy. Like today at work someone brought in doughnuts, so I took some home to eat Friday. They all know I don't touch junk food except one day per week.
 
I've been letting myself do that once a week too. It doesn't hurt anything.

It's every Saturday now. I go to my favorite Indian restaurant (PR knows the one!) and load up on stuff undoubtedly full of ghee, plus a celestial deep fried cauliflower dish and (gasp) white rice, with a watermelon chaser. Then, a couple of oatmeal cookies when I get home. I always work out extra hard that day though to try and make the guilt a little more palatable.
 
I don't have much time left to reply, but it seems to me that they did not measure calories or HOW MUCH the women ate. The article only describes what they ate. Junk food has more calories than healthy food.

I just can't believe that if you eat more calories than you burn off--no matter what type of calories they are, protein or fruit or vegetables--that you won't gain weight.


Jeanne
 
I agree Jeanne. I don't believe the myth that some calories are better than others, i.e. low carb diet. Back in the early 90's I only counted fat grams. I lost weight but looking back I realize that I was eating a low calorie diet because I was a poor college student who couldn't afford those expensive low fat high calorie foods like Snackwells. Now I count calories but what I've realized is that when I eat healthy I automatically eat low calorie. Vegetables and fruits have hardly any calories and really fill me up. But when I start eating junk food, I get hungry and want more and then end up eating too many calories.
 
Jeanne..

I don't think the article stated that, did it?? I think it just said WHAT you eat is more important than HOW MUCH you eat when it comes to your obesity risk. If you eat clean, healthy food you are less likely to be obese later in life. This study is probably factoring in all of us here on this forum that know not too eat too much either. Most people that make the effort to eat clean and healthy are not stuffing their face. And if they are, somehow they are managing to burn it off, atleast to the extent in which they are not yet considered "obese". Think of how little you can eat with the high-fat alternatives. Combine that with a sedentary lifestyle and you probably will be obese in no time.

I think that was the jist of it......
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top