Mad At My Sister In Law

Madonna

Cathlete
My brother and his wife are having major marital problems and I think a divorce is coming soon. I have spoken with my brother about several sensitive issues regarding our entire family including his marriage, our parents' will, etc. Afterward, my sister in law called me and asked me not to tell my brother things that would upset him. I was furious. My feeling is that wives may come and go but he will always be MY brother. My feeling is that I can say to him whatever I want, whenever I want.

My sister in law is trying to talk to me now and I am avoiding her because I am still so mad. She sent me an email message asking me if I was mad. I never told her how I truly feel because I was so mad that I would have said something really mean. I can't keep avoiding her. What should I do?


Madonna
 
Just my humble opinion, but I think you should make an effort to talk to her after you've had a chance to breathe for a while. Yes, he is your brother, but whatever their problems are now, he did marry her. Perhaps you can find a way to say what you said here without being mean to her? I'm sure she'd understand how you feel about him, especially if she herself has siblings. You don't say what their problems are, but she might be feeling things you aren't aware of right now, and perhaps she didn't mean to make you angry by what she said, but was only showing concern for your brother. Just talk to her, and try to patch things up. I'm sorry their marriage might be ending. It must put you in an awkward position with her. I hope things work out.

Carol
:)
 
Ok.. Im gonna take the OTHER side.... Your loyalty should be to your brother not your SIL. If they are going to split it could get ugly. I've been through it. Tell her that your loyalties are to your brother and you don't want to be brought between him. I TOTALLY agree with you SILs may come and go but he is always your brother and you had a relationship with him long before she came along. You can talk to him whenever you want...

My current SIL bitched about my brother putting $500 towards my elderly mothers move. I put in 1,300. SHe sent a NASTY letter to me, my brother and my 80+ year old mother. I replied to my sil... and said at this point I dont want to continue a relationship with her but I hope it will not effect my relationship with my brother or my daughter. My kids are teenagers so they can chose if they want to be in touch with her.. but i don't want to. (this happened 2 days ago)

I'm divorced and have a wonderful relationship with my ex SIL... the reason why I NEVER NEVER complained to her at all about my ex, I shielded her from any of our issues.

SO yes stay loyal to your brother. I would not try to patch things up.. she will probably just try to bring you into the battle. Keep your distance from her. Try to be civil but keep your distance.
 
I totally disagree.

You don't know for certain that a divorce is imminent. That may be wishful thinking on your part. Only they know for sure what is happening in their relationship. I would, personally, stay well out of it. It's not anyone else's affair. But you certainly should discuss other family matters, such as your parents' will, with him.

I think it is untrue to say that a family member will remain as important to a sibling as their spouse. I think actually that the reverse is true and that the pattern of switched allegiances is perfectly normal. My husband is more important to me that any family member. That's how it should be. He is my life. He is the one who knows me best, with whom I share incredible intimacy. No other family member can know us or be quite as close to us as a spouse.

Personally, I think she may have something here. I have, in the past, spoken to my brother in law and said the same thing to him as your SIL says to you: please do not discuss certain matters with him, he is under enough presure right now. The reason? The spouse knows better than a sister or brother exactly what pressures the other spouse is under. She knows him better than you do: bottom line. Maybe she really is trying to help him, protect him in some way.

I think you need to control your anger toward her. Dissipate it somewhere else. Don't participate in their spousal problems: that's what your SIL is really trying to tell you. I would do the same if my husband's family wanted to interefere in my relationship with him, however bad it got.

If your brother seeks your input, that's something else, and that's up to him. Ideally, wives do not "just come and go" as you mistakenly think. To believe your SIL to be so negligible is not respectful at all. I don't think it does your brother a great service either: what does it say about his character?

Calm down: take a step back from someone else's affairs, then address with your brother the affairs that have to do with your joint parents. The rest I would leave well alone.

You may not like what I have to say here. I have been honest and you have the right to ignore it as you wish. But, there are always different sides to a problem, and sometimes it can hurt to be forced to entertain another perspective. But also, it can be productive.

I wish you well, and above all, I hope your brother can sort out his marital problems successfully. :)

Clare
 
I would continue to speak to her but avoid any family issues esp if she wants to discuss your brother. Maybe tell her that if your brother is uncomfortable with you speaking to him about things than he needs to tell you what bothers him. You might want to talk to him first and tell him what she said to see if he knows what he said that made her tell you not to speak to him. Good luck. I have my own in law issues due to the ex wife still involved with DH's family so I can understand your feelings on this.
 
Good point Marie -

I can tell you have been through the ex SIL thing. Agree talk to your brother first tell him what she said. He is your brother and you can tell her anything that she says to you will go back to your brother....

I had a horrible sil (brother's first) she use to call me constantly complaining about him. At first I didn't tell him but finally I did. She use to call me with the intimate details of things and complain. Hello - how stupid can you be calling your husband's sister and complaining about him...

So based on that experience, i would clearly tell her you are not a sounding board for issues with you brother.

good luck
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top