Wow...I forgot there was a new thread today until Melody just kindly alerted us in the 5.8 thread. I somehow altogether missed that today was Wednesday. I'm sorry Mel!!!
Now regarding your thread. After you spend a few minutes breathing deeply and practising the yoga relaxation techniques that you are SO GOOD AT, and which you kicked your dear children out of the loft for, we shall go into the topic at hand.
There are different ways to achieve goals. Thankfully Cathe doesn't have only one workout DVD (although my dh may argue this point of view). There are many methods of training. What works for one may not work for another. In my case...I generally have to do it all to get to where I want to be. I try everything.
My opinion for achieving chins is this....if the negatives aren't causing you problems or pain (as in Soosan's case), then keep doing them, day in and day out, come rain or shine, through thick and through thin, until death due us part (even while doing normal chins). BUT, you may try bands which give you a little bit of assistance which is what Kathryn is trying. I'm STILL a firm believer in the eccentric chinup....they will strengthen your back. Since you can do these without significant problems....then do them! Don't worry about bandy, stooly, gidgets and gadgets that can break things (did that sound like Tony or what???) (too much P90X over here). Just get on that bar and get going.
Don't stress this Melody!! Don't get confused...just do negatives. Oh yes...do those inverts too...they are sooo coool.
Briee