Geez - I'm afraid to give my opinion cuz I thought Kelly Coffey's Step Kickboxing was intense enough cardio and someone else posted saying it wasn't..............but I didn't mean it was Imax intense.
I think Barry's is pretty intense. There is a different cardio on each DVD ...totally different and each instructor uses a lot of plyos. I don't think they have a cool/down stretch either. Can't remember for sure. I wouldn't call the cardio "Imax intense" for the total 20 minutes but I think they are intense enough to be what they are supposed to be, which is a shorter, intense cardio. They use an extremely high step (almost unsafe looking to me ......about 4-5 risers) and I didn't even use that high of a step and got a good enough workout. I like that they have the treadmill option also.......which I hope to use next time.
As far as the weights go, there are some different moves...that's for sure and I think that's the best thing about these. I remember Barry doing a lot of isometric holds which seemed to work differently than a Cathe. I guess the intensity of the weights would really depend on the amount of weight you lifted. From what I remember, they are higher rep workouts....so everyone would need to find their failure poundage. It might take some playing around with (which is normal).
The only reason I would call these not as intense as a Cathe workout is because of the time factor. I think each weight/cardio segment can be done in around an hour. Some are slightly over the hour....can't remember. If you really wanted intense, you could do 2 weights and 2 cardio's back to back...........and I think if you didn't think that was intense enough.....than you're possibly not human??
I know when I first got them, I was so enthusiastic about them that I did 2 cardio segments back to back as a cardio workout one day and it was pretty tough. I never did it again....cuz I think I remember my joints aching a bit......but I do have to modify some of Cathe's air jacks and tuck jumps on my rebounder due to back problems......so maybe it would be fine for others.
I'd just hate to give my opinion here and have someone buy them and be disappointed. I find them pretty tough and can't believe they are even trying to market them to the HSN audience! (There's an idea....check out HSN.com and see what the price is there....maybe it's cheaper).