I have both. I really like Push because I love all of Kari's aerobics, especially the step (my favorites are United Steps, Body Tech, and Hot Step). I am too much of a klutz for Reach. I just couldn't do a lot of the balance moves and did not feel as though I had much of a workout that day. (I pulled it off the shelf on one of those sweltering humid days when I felt enervated before I even started, so it was okay.)Overall, though, I would rather do weights for strength. Not sure what I will do with Reach! Maybe I'll try it another time.....some day.