I have just finshed putting both my girls through 6 years each of elementary school and have experienced a wide range of fund raising activities.
There were some that were universally appealing and very successful and others that I hated and boycotted.
I hated the expensive gift wrap catalogs that the kids were supposed to sell to friends and relatives. It encourages waste, none of it was recycled and I couldn't afford the prices. I also loated the ones that got the kids to sell unhealthy foods to their friends and family, fat-laden desserts, and all sorts of crappy foods that no-one should be eating. So, I was against those on principle.
I supported the Spring plant ales for a couple of years, then had to stop. If you follow this route, you must make sure your supplier is giving you high quality plants. I would spend $30 on bedding plants only to have the whole lot fail to thrive. But the plants I replaced them with and had purchased a local garden centre sale thrived. So, I resented having felt like I had gotten a pig-in-a-poke.
Here are the ideas that worked and were loved:
1. Winter carnival.
It was so good to have an idea that got nearly thw whole school to come out in freezing Michigan winter to come and have several hours of fun. And people always came in droves! Parking was at a premium! It included stacks of fun games, easily played inside, little presents that were rubbish really but the kids love them! A cake walk (parents donated the baked goods), and food for sale (hot dogs, pizza, sodas, juices, etc)
2. Ice cream social in June, last week of school.
Similar to Winter carnival in terms of food for sale, and games, but games could be bigger and take up more space because played outside. It alo included ice cream, and a dunk tank where some teachers took turns waiting to be dunked if the kids threw the ball and hit the buzer. These teachers were always good sports and this one game drew the crowds from home. Who wouldn't want to see their principal in shorts and wet tee, especially if he hoses the crowd back with his water pistol!!
3. Scholastic Book Fair.
This one is always hosted in the run up to Christmas, allowing parents to get new books at discount as presents for their kids, school always gets part of the proceeds. I helped out with this every year and loved it. Who wouldn't want to promote reading while raising money for the school?
4. Movie nights.
Every so often, we would gather in the main hall, bring a blanket for the family, buy a pizza for the whole family and watch a movie with friends from the school. All goof family entertainment on a bigger screen.
Generally speaking I am against fundraisers that require kids to beg family and relatives to keep buying crappy, over-priced stuff from them. I don't want others sighing when they see my kids at their door toting a glossy catalog. It gets old real quick. Neither do I want them knocking on strangers' doors. Not in today's world thank you.
So, from a parent's perspective, this is what works and what doesn't.
Clare