Hi KathyH,
First, I agree with what Angela said above.
I've also learned the hard way that I was really eating more cals than I really needed. It's really hard to face it at first. I thought I was going to starve to death or screw up my metabolism further, but I think it was mostly because I didn't want to give up my food. This way seemed drastic, but once you learn how to eat and feel satisfied, it's worth it. I've love the results so far.
I mean, I stayed roughly at the same weight for one year. I tried around 1200 cal, then that didn't really work. So then I tried upping my cals, because I read so much about not getting enough fuel which could stall weightloss. Nope, that didn't worked either. I even tried even a little higher. I tried differnt workouts, or added this and that and still no results. Then, I was left to believe that I maybe I was at set point and I wasn't going to get below 120, st least not this 5' person.
I know I'm stronger now than when I started out with LL. So, I'm pretty sure I'm not losing more muscle mass than fat. I've pretty much hit my maxes at home and I may have to move my stength training to the gym. I can't lift anymore than 65lbs over my head without falling backwards, I think. I know I can squat much more than that, but I'm limited right now.
As of today, my waist has a total reduction of 1". I couldn't get my waist to budge one bit prior to LL. My losses show mostly in inches, not so much in pounds.
The Nutrition Analyzer uses the same chart(U.S. Dept. of Agriculture's Nutrient database for Standard Reference) that Fit-day uses. I usually enter foods through "Custom Foods." It's easier when you have the packaging to enter the nutrtional info yourself. Then you can combine your foofds to make meals. It's eaiser to enter that way, but not always. I hardly eat anything that is processed, too.
Your shake may need to be reduced in cals or porportioned to the ratios you need per meal. Is 360 cals a shake something that you make at home or is it premade? It could be okay for certain indiviuals and the right amount for their needs, but necessarily yours. One size doesn't fit all. Something that I've learned also. I also do not waste my cals on bars or shakes because of how much they consume of my caloric intake per day. Plus, the fullness(or satifisfaction) doesn't last long enough. With that said, I ocassionaly due sometimes because I have no other chioce than to starve.
Also, I cut bars into 3 or 4 pieces. When I feel like I'm starving, I grab one and drink water. In 20 min. I'm fine. Normally, I would have eaten the whole bar and consumed an extra 200 some cals that I really didn't need. I also use cut bars to get my ratios to work out when I need extra protein to balance out my meal.
I can eat platefuls of food for 360 cals. That would more than 1/4th of your calories coming from a shake. Honestly, if you do that, you most likely will find yourself really hungry and miserable.
Doing this program has taught me how well(and extremely healthy) I can eat when faced with limited calories. It's okay to have some of your meal in higher cals, but you just try your best to get the ratios as close as possibly as you can.
I usually make a whole wheat pancake that turn out to be about 8-10" round. It calls for 1/3 cup of the whole wheat mix, eggs whites, water and so on. On a day that I need to drop a few cals lower, I just reduce the serving of it a bit and add a little extra water. I hardly even notice the difference. It's still 8-10" round, but perhaps a hair thinner. Saves about 40-50 cal just in breakfast alone. It's eaiser to eat your normal foods, but then find something than can be reduced or taken out or replaced with lower filling foods.
Your calculations seem to line up with mine. I'm not sure how much activity you entered per week, but if want higher cals then either add more vigorous exercise or reduce how much you want to lose per week. Give a week or so. Although, any new way of eating and working out is pretty tough the first week or two.
Got an email from LL: their site is having problems and may not be back in gear until Thursday. It does still let me in, but I think it sporadically picks based upon you service provider.