If you see it, you'll eat it, expert says (LONG)

andtckrtoo

Cathlete
Interesting article from CNN (and I know it's true for me!): http://www.cnn.com/2007/HEALTH/diet.fitness/09/21/kd.mindless.eating/index.html

ITHACA, New York (CNN) -- We are powerless to ignore the clarion call of the candy jar, the beckoning of the buffet, the summons of the snack cupboard.

At the Cornell Food and Brand Lab, Professor Brian Wansink studies how people behave around food.

That's the conclusion of Brian Wansink, author of "Mindless Eating" and head of Cornell University's Food and Brand Lab.

Wansink has spent a career watching how people behave around food -- at home and work, in sit-down restaurants and buffets, and in the many other places where Americans routinely chow down.

"We believe we have all the free will in the world. We believe we overeat if the food is good or if we're really hungry. In reality, those are two of the last things that determine how much we eat," Wansink says. What really influences our eating, he says, are visibility and convenience.

In one experiment, Wansink placed candy jars of chocolate in office workers' cubicles for a month. Then, he moved the candy six feet away. Simply having the candy closer meant the office workers ate five more candies a day. That adds up to 125 calories a day, or 12 pounds a year.

"Something that's very visible, every time we see it we have to make a decision. Do I want to eat that? Do I not want to eat that? Do I want that candy on my desk, or do I not want it? We can say no 27 times, but if it's visible, the 28th or 29th time, we start saying, 'Maybe.' By time 30, 31, we start saying, 'What the heck? I'm hungry,' " Wansink says.

"In a similar way, convenience also tends to do the same thing. If it's really convenient and there's nothing to stop us from reaching out and grabbing something, we'll continue to do something until something tells us to stop."

In one telling experiment, Wansink divided a group of 150 test subjects into three, giving a third canisters of potato chips with every seventh chip dyed red. Another third received canisters with every 14th chip dyed. Other ate from canisters with no dyed chips.

Test subjects with no dyed chips ate an average of 23 chips; those with every 14th chip dyed red ate an average of 15; those with every seventh chip dyed red ate an average of 10.

The red chips provided what Wansink calls a "pause point," an interruption that forces the eater to ask whether he or she wants to eat more. For this reason, Wansink says the 100-calorie containers of chips or cookies work to help 70 percent of people eat less. When they finish the container, they pause and ask themselves whether they want more.

Wansink has found you'll eat more if you're eating:

• "family style" with the serving bowls on the table.

• directly from the bag or carton.

• on a bigger plate or from a bigger container.

• in front of the television, in the car, with friends.

Even if we know all about mindless eating, Wansink says we can't help ourselves. He's proven this point by giving a 90-minute class to graduate students about eating more from larger containers and then secretly observing them at a Super Bowl party six weeks later.

Wansink's solution: Surrender. Accept that you will give in to temptation and eat mindlessly.

What really influences our eating, he says, are visibility and convenience. Keep healthy snacks close at hand.

"When it comes down to it, we're efficient people," Wansink says. "We want something that's convenient. And if it's fruit or vegetables that's a whole lot more convenient than that cake that's wrapped up in the freezer, guess what's for snack today? Fruits and vegetables."
 
Hmmmm not sure I buy that. If I were a guinea pig, & I was sitting in front of a Hershey bar & a celery stick, I'd go for the chocolate every time. EVERY TIME I say! :+
 
Hmmm, a study to study the obvious. I'm a tad disappointed with the folks at Cornell.
 
Hmmmm....not so sure.

I sit with a candy jar 2 feet from me and another larger one 10 feet from me with bags of chips,popcorn, etc. Jars are filled with snickers, reeses pb cups,etc.

I don't touch them. In a year and a half I've had maybe 3 pieces of chocolate from them and I LOVE chocolate. I won't allow myself to eat from them...off limits in my head.
 
Certainly some have the willpower to resist...if you're one of them kudos to you!

Unfortunately, I don't think most of us are regularly that disciplined...
 
I totally buy it!

We have candy jars in our office that are for the clients when they come in - its almost inevitible that EVERY person who passes the candy jar picks out one of the "mini" candies that are available.

They now offer single wrapped licorice and lollipops and plain mints as well because I was disgusted that the only form of sweets was chocolate - granted its not the dried fruit snacks that I had wanted but its a start!

I have my own stash of dried fruit and granola bars to keep me away from the candy container! If I want chocolate, I would go for dark chocolate anyways and nobody really has that around here......which is a good thing!
 
I read his book and it was very interesting. Kind of depressing in places, but interesting. I recommend checking it out of the library.
 

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top