American Idol

S

sarab

Cathlete
It is that time of the week again!! What did you all think?? Here is what I like...IMHO....

Katherine: Yuck. She did not do very well singing Whitney. She should stick to Christina. Although, (I sound like Paula) she is very beautiful!!

Elliott: Awesome

Paris: Yuck.

Kelly: Triple yuck!

Taylor: Yuck...I just don't care for him much. I think he is boring.

Chris: Whooooo Hooooooo!!!! That guy is awesome!!!!!! His wife is a lucky, lucky woman!!!

I think the bottom 3 will be Kelly, Katherine, and Paris.

Sara

http://www.picturetrail.com/saraburnham1
 
The best part of the show was Simon cracking up at Paula crying.

Katherine - OK song, fix the pantylines! She sure is beautiful, and I cracked up at Ryan's crack about turning down the volume and still voting for her.

Elliott was great and I only voted for him....a lot

Paris - OK, girl can sing, but there is always something missing.

Kelly - girl cannot sing, go home....but she won't

Taylor - I was warming up to Taylor recently, but this just did not do it

Chris - I usually love anything he does, but this did not snag me, still like to look at him though }(


Bottom 3 Paris, Chris, and hopefully Kellie, going home Paris(Kellie should, but she has a fan base). Probably wrong, I usually am!

I think Paula was on a new drug last night.
 
I think the bottom 2 should be Kelly and Katherine. Kelly should go home. I don't know who the 3rd would be. I am not a huge Elliot fan and wasn't really thrilled with his performance though he brought Paula to tears! I missed Paris, but saw her bit at the very end. I thought it sounded weird, ...

Chris is my favorite and I hope he takes it all!

I didn't think Taylor did as poorly as they said. My hubby really likes him.

Susan
 
Kelly: was horrible..what the hell with that hair??
Taylor: was SO flat, it was awful!
Paris: tried too hard it seemed strained, but sounded wonderful
Elliot: did well, but Paula is out of her freaking mind!
Katherine: did a decent job, did not like her hair like that.
Chris: I think he did very well, I was not crazy about that song though.

Bottom 3 will be:
Taylor, Kelly, Paris

Kelly will get voted off I think.
 
There's just something about Elliott! He was great last night, but Taylor wasn't at his best.

I can only hope Kelly goes home. Please, put us all out of our misery and send her home!!!!!

"It is better to keep your mouth closed and let people think you are a fool than to open it and remove all doubt." Mark Twain ;-)
 
Well Elliott grabbed my attention, but Chris took it all!!!!!

Kelly is just pathetic. She says alot of negative uncool things when she is done. She needs to shut up!!!!!! She deserves to be going home tonight. Her hair looks like mine when I straighten my hair. I always pull the top back like that and flat iron the sides, back...could never imagine going on stage looking like that.

Paris was good

I actually liked the song Taylor sang last night. It was just good, not anything earth shaking.

Katharine is beautiful. I was busy looking at her hair and dress. Thinking, I could do my hair like hers, etc. The song was not much. Too bad.


And what is up with Paula? Same drugs? She is so fake! Robotic. I just wish someone else was in her place...someone cool ...someone REAL cuz she isn't. Why did she cry like that over Elliott???? Should have cried over Chris instead, but why cry at all???? Strange woman. She didn't look well either.

Wish Ryan would go back to wearing his jeans and cool t-shirts like before too.

Charlotte~~
 
Charlotte, I'm with you. My overwhelming question was, who swapped Paula's medication???? There is something SERIOUSLY wrong with that woman.

I thought Kelly and Taylor were the worst. I didn't think anyone else was particularly good, even Chris. I mean, he was the best of the worst, but it wasn't a great song or rendition.

Marie
 
>Charlotte, I'm with you. My overwhelming question was, who
>swapped Paula's medication???? There is something SERIOUSLY
>wrong with that woman.
>
>I thought Kelly and Taylor were the worst. I didn't think
>anyone else was particularly good, even Chris. I mean, he was
>the best of the worst, but it wasn't a great song or
>rendition.
>
>Marie


I agree except I liked Elliot best. I think Elliot, Chris, and Katherine are the best of the group that are left. Paris is a good singer but maybe just needs more time and too young yet. I think Kelly and Taylor should be the next 2 to leave. But based on Kelly's performance last week and still not being in the bottom 3, voting is so unpredictable.
 
Chris and Elliot rocked the house tonight. The girls...well...phhhhbt. Kellie was the worst, followed by Paris. I'd really like to see those 2 ladies go bye bye.


"you miss 100% of the shots you never take"


Debbie
 
I think Kellie, Katherine and Taylor are the bottom 3 (but whether they will end up there is another story).

I love the song Kellie sang but I HATED her rendition of it. And her way of pronouncing some vowels when she sings is annoying.

Katherine seemed to hit more sour notes than good.

And Taylor was pretty blah.

"America' might put Paris in the bottom 3 because she chooses songs that sound 'old."

I'm more than ready to see Kellie go!

Katherine would be my second choice for the boot.

I'd be sorry to see anyone else leave.
 
>WHAT IS PAULA ON???

And what's with her compulsion to always tell everyone how good they look? If a MAN said that, it would often seem sexist or out of place: judging people on their appearance.
 
Okay, I'll give my two cents.

I thought Chris was the best last night, of the guys and the girls.
I thought Katharine (or Kellie? don't throw anything at me! haha!) was the best of the girls.

Eliot was second best I thought.
Paris can sing, that's for sure, but I agree that something is missing.
Taylor I thought was kinda blah last night.

I think the bottom 3 will be Kellie, Taylor, and Paris. And I guess Kellie should go *tear tear*

Edited to say I agree Paula must be on something...I don't understand the crying over Elliots song!?!?!
 
Honestly, I think Paula talks about how they look because she doesn't have anything intelligent to say about the vocals or the arrangement.

Marie
 
I think that the bottom 3 should be, but probably won't be, Kelly, Taylor, and Paris. I don't know who is going home for sure yet. People shock me when they vote. Kelly drives me crazy, dh and I were tivoing the show and fast forwarded her performance after the first minute. It was painful. That's who I would like to see go.
I voted for Chris last night, but only once. It was very hard to get through. (I hope that's a good thing!)

Kathy
 
I thought Elliott was awesome and so was chris. I thought Kelli was horrible and I don't think Taylor was that good and I usually love him. I hope that Kelli goes home. I think that Paula really is losing it. Let's hope that Kelli or Paris goes home tonight.

Susan
 
Oh, and another thing...what was up with all the numbers for voting? I mean I know they might need to open up another line so everyone can vote, but I think it might have been confusing last night for some and wondering if ALOT of people voted for the wrong ones by mistake...know what I mean? So it will be scary who will be in the bottom three tonight. Could be the ones that actually were the better ones because of this. Never know. OH, PLEASE DON'T LET CHRIS GO HOME!!!!! NOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Charlotte~~
 
Paula should go home!! Permanently!! That woman needs some serious help, and quickly. What on earth is she taking, and why do they continue to let her show up high/drunk/whatever the he** she is on a LIVE show which CHILDREN watch?????????????

I did not like Kelly this week. I think it's time for her to go. I thought Katherine did very well, but that dress was way too tight on her. Paris did all right, but there's just something about her I can't warm up to. Elliot blew me away!! Chris did great, but Taylor sounded off last night. I do like him though and still hope he's in the final two.

Can't wait to hear Andrea sing!!!! What an incredible talent!!

Carol
:)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Our Newsletter

Get awesome content delivered straight to your inbox.

Top