Featherbed or Memory Foam Mattress Topper?

[workout junkie]

DH and I got a new firmer mattress because our pillowtop was too mushy. But maybe our new one is too firm. We're thinking of getting a featherbed topper or a memory foam one. Any thoughts?

Thanks,
Melissa

 

[beautifulsoul]

I have a featherbed topper on mine, it is so comfy. I've never tried the memory foam. Sorry not much help.

 

[acatalina]

I have a 4'Memoey foam on my bed., and i bought 3' ones for the spares. My dh has never complained about it or his back hurting in the am. since.
Only prob is i have to use 2 fitted sheets. I hace a pillow top mattress and it is just too thick together.. Oh, and i bought the fitted cover for the memory foam.
I love mine...
Anne
http://www.picturetrail.com/acatalina

 

[alsrnbsn]

I have both and love them!!! I have the 3' topper and the feather bed (I can't remember which is on top of which) and actually hate sleeping on any other bed!

 

[Sunshine 1528]

We have a foam based bed with 4" of memory foam ontop. I have never slept better this pasy year and a half. Always comfy - the only disadvantage is it will be warmer than a standard mattress. But that hasn't bothered me - was actually really nice this past winter as I didn't have to add two more blankets since we keep our heater at 55.