Most fitness experts recommend a combination of aerobic exercise and resistance training to build muscle strength and boost aerobic capacity and heart health. Traditionally, cardio exercises such as running, aerobics or cycling were thought to be best for cardiovascular training and resistance workouts best for building muscle strength. But these days more people are using circuit resistance training as a substitute for aerobics. With circuit resistance training, you move from one strength exercise to the next with little rest between sets. This elevates the heart rate more than traditional weight training where there are longer rest periods between exercises. Is circuit resistance training a good substitute for cardio?
Do You Need to Do Cardio if You Lift Weights?
Most people prefer strength training over running or cycling on an exercise bike. They’d rather flex their muscles with weights than spend 30 minutes working out on a cardio machine. It would be music to their ears to find out that circuit resistance training conditions their heart, as well as traditional aerobic exercise, does. Unfortunately, this may not be the case.
It’s logical to think that resistance training boosts aerobic capacity. After all, your heart rate goes up when you lift weights, and it’s elevated even more when you do circuit style training. There are some differences though.
When you do one of my aerobic videos or run on a treadmill, your heart rate increases along with stroke volume which is the amount of blood the heart pumps to the body with each beat. This increase in heart rate and stroke volume allows muscles that are now more metabolically active to receive greater amounts of blood and oxygen.
When you lift weights or do some other form of resistance exercise, your heart rate rises, but stroke volume and oxygen delivery don’t increase like they do with aerobic exercise. The increase in heart rate that occurs with resistance training is a reflex response that’s triggered by muscle contraction. As a result, you don’t get the same increase in oxygen delivery to the muscles with resistance training. This reduces cardiovascular training benefits.
Does Circuit Resistance Training Have Cardiovascular Benefits?
Resistance training with periods of rest between sets has little cardiovascular training effect. If you minimize the amount of time you rest between sets to 30 seconds or less, you get slightly more benefits but not equivalent to what you’d get during an aerobics class, running on a treadmill or cycling on a bike. According to ACE Fitness, circuit resistance training boosts aerobic capacity around 6%. In contrast, running and cycling can increase aerobic capacity by as much as 25%.
Does This Mean You Have to Do Traditional Cardio to Train Your Heart?
Circuit resistance training may not be the best way to increase your aerobic capacity, but there are ways to make it better. Instead of doing straight circuit training, do 1-minute cardio segment between each resistance training exercise. When you finish each strength set, grab a jump rope and skip rope for a minute, do jumping jacks or run in place before picking up the weights again. This will give your heart the additional stimulus it needs to adapt without doing traditional cardio.
Resistance Training Has Other Benefits
Even though resistance training alone doesn’t significantly increase aerobic capacity, it does indirectly benefit the heart. Research shows that circuit-style resistance training helps to reduce blood pressure over time in some subjects. Aside from its effects on the heart, it also increases lean body mass, bone density and improves strength. Almost everyone can benefit from some form of resistance training.
The Bottom Line?
Resistance training has benefits, but it isn’t a good substitute for cardio. Circuit resistance training can modestly improve aerobic capacity but not as much as cardiovascular exercises like aerobic classes, running or cycling. To improve the cardiovascular benefits of resistance training, do short intervals of cardio between each resistance set. Otherwise, keep strength training, but make time for cardio too.
References:
ACE Fitness. “Why Is an Elevated Heart Rate Alone Not Always a Valid Indicator of an Effective Aerobic-Training Stimulus?”
Medscape.com. “Strength Training and Hemodynamic Responses to Exercise: Summary and Clinical Application”
Medscape.com. “Endurance Exercise and Resistance Training in Cardiovascular Disease: Benefits of Resistance Training”
Related Articles By Cathe:
Are You Making These Circuit Training Mistakes?
What Impact Does Resistance Training Have on Heart Health? American College of Cardiology Weighs In
5 Powerful Reasons to Do a Circuit Workout
Can Circuit Training Help You Meet All of Your Fitness Goals?
Can Circuit Training Be a Substitute for Standard Weight Training?
This is very good information I make sure that I get my cardio in every single day, because it’s good for the heart and burns fat! You have to burn fat in order to see the muscles that you are developing. Great info! I’m a Cathlete!!!
Thanks for clarifying this…fitness info can be so confusing in a frustrating way at times especially when various pundits try to promote one method over another. An example…there seems to be an increasing movement in fitness towards promoting circuit weight training as a cardio substitute.
This is the same thing that Crowley and Lodge talk about in the book, “Younger Next Year.” It’s just good exercise sense. Cardio is good for you!
So, just to clarify, which of Cathe’s videos are classified as “circuit resistance training?” I’m thinking, after reading the article, ones like Supersets and Push/Pull, but haven’t ever really thought of these as “circuits.” To me, a circuit includes a little cardio, say more like Low Impact Circuit or High Step Training. I’d appreciate some more info on which videos might be considered circuit resistance training, so I can be sure to add some cardio those days.